[Rate this line-up] - Full list w/ links (1 Viewer)

[PocketAces]

I feel like we have covered a lot of ground with this series, thanks to all of you who have taken the time to provide pictures, vote and comment. If you haven't voted yet, I encourage you to do so. Full list of links below. If you have a high quality picure of a sample (not a set picture, no barrel or rack pictures) that hasn't made the list yet, please reach out. And if anyone knows how we could have scores updated live in a chart in this thread that would be great (@RainmanTrail?). I think that, as of now, PCF favorite line up is the Grand Casino Gulfport!

[Casino]
Antique Rose
Aviation Club de France (Tournament)
Bahamia
Binion's Horsehoe
Bourbon Street
California Club
Casa Royale
Commerce Casino (tournament)
Copa Casino
Delta Club
DOC's cardroom
Dolphin Cruise Line
El Condor
Grand Casino (Gulfport)
Huntington Park
Indio Bingo Palace
Lady Luck (Caruthersville)
Lake Elsinore
Lakeshore Inn
Mapes Hotel & Casino
Macon County
Nevada Hotel & Casino
Nevada Lodge
Niles Point (D&D Cardroom)
Oceanside Card Club (cash)
Oceanside Card Club (tournament)
The Outpost (San Ramon)
Palm Beach Cruise Line
President Casino on the Admiral (Secondary)
President Casino New Yorker
Rainbow Club
Regency Cruise
Rio WSOP
Silver Saddle
Silver Star
Starlite Cruises
Stateline Saloon & Gambling Hall
Stockyard Inn
Tropicana (1st edition)
Village Club
Wynn (Tournament)
Yosemite Inn

[NAGB]
AS Tournament
AS cash
BTP cash
ESST
ESPT
ES cash
RPC cash #1
RPC cash #2
RPC tournament #1
Sunset Beach cash
Tiger Palace primary cash
Tiger Palace secondary cash

[Fantasy]
20th Century
King's Crown
WTHC

 

[davislane]

Thank you for your service

 

[PocketAces]

Used this opportunity to update pictures for:
- Delta Club (missing frac)
- Grand Casino Gulfport (missing high denoms)
- Lake Elsinore (missing $100)
- Lakeshore Inn (picture quality)

 

[tablescraps]

Thanks for creating this series. It was great to see what other people think about some of the sets that I own.

 

[PocketAces]

Picked up a few line ups I’m tracking to see how they were ranked (not the definite rank as I didn’t check them all)

GC Gulfport 85%
Silver Star 82.09%
Starlite Cruise 81.07%
Silver Saddle 79.59%
Indio Bingo Palace 78.75%
Delta Club 78.4%
Yosemite Inn 75.88%
Lakeshore Inn 75.81%
Huntington Park 75.38%
Oceanside CC (cash) 73.83%
Regency Cruise 73.24%
Tropicana 1st edition 72.2%
PCA secondary 71.55%
Mapes Hotel & C 68.71%
Lake Elsinore 67.39% (booooo! Underrated!?)
Nevada Lodge 66.77% (completely underrated imo)


Now the NAGBs aren’t doing too bad considering the bad press they get…

Just looking at NAGB cash sets
Empress Star 66.79%
RPC #2 66.59%
Sunset B 66.59%
BTP 66.03%
Aurora Star 61.21%
RPC #1 56.09% (booooo)

 

[doublebooyah85]

Booyah! This is awesome.

Is this their average score? Not sure I follow the %

Are you saying Gulfport had an average score of 8.5?

 

[PocketAces]

Booyah! This is awesome.

Is this their average score? Not sure I follow the %

Are you saying Gulfport had an average score of 8.5?

Yes exactly. Converted average scores to %. To be clear I didn’t look through the entire list. Just the ones I track.

 

[MeridianFC]

Well I just burned a good 30 minutes voting on these old threads.

 

[MeridianFC]

Just looking at NAGB cash sets
Empress Star 66.79%
RPC #2 66.59%
Sunset B 66.59%
BTP 66.03%
Aurora Star 61.21%
RPC #1 56.09% (booooo)

That's just crazy, the design on some of those is some of the best ever. Paulson maximized. I know there is (very understandable) bad blood surrounding these, thankfully it happened while I wasn't around so I'm not completely tainted by the broohaha. Then again I am tainted by not being able to own them.

 

[mburnznj]

Awesome list and awesome reviews. The hard work was appreciated! I am jealous of some of those sets out there.

I'm curious how FLV and VLV would rank on this list under the fantasy tab.

 

[PocketAces]

I think it’s time we add the Tiger Palace to the list.

Anyone has high quality pictures in good lighting of the following?
1. primary cash set low stakes (fracs to $100)
2. primary cash set high stakes ($25 to 25k)
3. secondary cash set low stakes (fracs to $100)
4. secondary cash set high stakes ($25 to 25k)
5. Full hotstamp set

 

[Rieguy]

Edited - Didn't realize these were single-chip line-ups. I can take the lower-stakes pics later if no one does in the interim.

 

[PocketAces]

Edited - Didn't realize these were single-chip line-ups. I can take the lower-stakes pics later if no one does in the interim.

Hoping @JeepologyOffroad and @kk405 can help

 

[PocketAces]

Added links for the TP cash line-ups

Still early (only 36 votes) but the secondary cash line-up is doing very well so far with an average of 8.14/10

 

[PocketAces]

Bored... so checked back how I voted. Surprised by some of my initial votes, changed a few of them and in the end...

Top scores (for me, /10)
Silver Saddle 10
Starlite Cruises 10
Commerce Casino (T) 9
Delta Club 9
Grand Casino (Gulfport) 9
Indio Bingo Palace 9
Lakeshore Inn 9
Regency Cruise 9
Yosemite Inn 9

And then a bunch of 8/10
California Club
Casa Royale
Huntington Park
Lake Elsinore
Macon County
Nevada Hotel & Casino
Nevada Lodge
Oceanside Card Club (cash)
Rio WSOP
Silver Star
Tropicana (1st edition)

Think I was a bit harsh on PCA sec (gave them a 7/10)

 

[London24]

Anyone know if it’s possible to export the voting data?

Would love to see who has the most ‘accurate’ opinion (e.g. closest to mean across all sets) and so should be crowned the official PCF Taste Spokesperson for all future line-ups.

Also to look at the standard deviation for each to see which sets are polarising vs. universally loved or hated.

And how sets cluster together for appeal and SD.

And how strong the correlation between aesthetic appeal and realised values is.

Chips + Data = My jam