I think it's an easy shove if acting first, or when facing a bet/raise from one player. But when two players are already all-in - with equal stacks, no less - I think the circumstances make it an easy fold, regardless of stack size.
I haven't revealed the hands yet other than my own, but here's the equities (I don't remember suits, but I don't think it mattered -- I don't think anyone was holding suited card).
I appreciate the comments, and I see the validity in a shove/call and a fold. I'm not sure how JJ is an "easy fold" when I had 3-5 BB's (IIRC, it was closer to 3 BB's). I was going to be on the BB in 4 hands and likely shoving with ATC rather than JJ. No antes in play, FYI.
here's some advice, just play premium hands, you only start with jacks or better if its good enough to call you've also got to be in there raising, tight but aggressive and I do mean aggressive, you've got to think of it as a war
I don't recall blinds, but I would guess there were 55ish BB's on the table.
And at the time I made the call, it was not confirmed that UTG+1 and Button had the same chip stack. Maybe I should have asked for a count (because then I would have known that one of them would likely knock the other out), but in my mind, I was shorter than both of them, so it didn't matter.