2020 Custom Set of the Year entry thread (now open) (2 Viewers)

Can't edit Post #2 anymore...


Best Overall Chipset of the Year entries
  1. JACK Casino Cardiff, @jr8719
  2. Free River Club: Edition 2020 43mm, @JustinInMN
  3. The Bank, @Kid_Eastwood
  4. HMK Tournament, @HMK
  5. Dunes tribute, @Odranoel77
  6. Horseshoe Pesta, @Coyote
  7. Bean Town Poker Solid Cali cash set, @sheikh617
  8. Parris Luxury Casino & Resort, @BonScot
  9. Cavalry Club at the Armory, @Psypher1000

Best Custom CPC Chipset of the Year entries
  1. Cavalry Club at the Armory, @Psypher1000

Best Relabel Chipset of the Year entries
  1. JACK Casino Cardiff, @jr8719
  2. Horseshoe Pesta, @Coyote
  3. Bean Town Poker Solid Cali cash set, @sheikh617
  4. Parris Luxury Casino & Resort, @BonScot

Best Ceramic/Hybrid Chipset of the Year entries
  1. Free River Club: Edition 2020 43mm, @JustinInMN
  2. The Bank, @Kid_Eastwood
  3. Dunes tribute, @Odranoel77

Best Hotstamp Chipset of the Year entries

Best Open Class Chipset of the Year entries
  1. HMK Tournament, @HMK
 
Last edited:
So I'll register my The Bank set. This my revisit of the The Post chips.

I'll enter additonal category "ceramic/hybrid".

https://www.pokerchipforum.com/threads/the-bank-sunfly-polyclay.53844/

full

full


They are PolyClay (39mm) from SunFly.
The H.O.R.S.E. plaques and dealer button have also been made by SunFly (PolyChrom).

And here's the Design Thread :
https://www.pokerchipforum.com/threads/the-bank-my-revisit-of-the-the-post-chips.50966/
 
Last edited:
HMK said:
Yeah, i'll enter. Don't know about categori though, i'll leave that to the organizer, but either ceramic hybrid or other since the MSK stuff is a big part of the set.
Click to expand...

Looks like a ceramic/hybrid set to me, with high denom plaques. I don't think anyone with a CDI set that had plaques would claim its not a Paulson set. This would qualify for the ceramic/hybrid category.

I changed my mind. Only because the high-denom MSK plaques are integral to this tournament set, I think this has to go into the Open Class. It wouldn't be fair for the other ceramic/hybrids to compete without having MSK plaques in their set.
 
I gladly nominate my Horseshoe Pesta 1895 set.
This is a relabelled set, so it definitely should go to that category (if you ask me, relabels shoudn't run at all for the main category, NOT being fully custom, but it seems the rules are different).
Horseshoe_4094.jpg
Horseshoe_4110.jpg
Horseshoe_4143.jpg
Horseshoe_4125.jpg
Horseshoe_4126.jpg
Horseshoe_4127.jpg
Horseshoe_4128.jpg
Horseshoe_4129.jpg



For the story behind the set, look here:
https://www.pokerchipforum.com/threads/horseshoe-pesta-1895-pr0n.54003/


Edit: Labels re-designed, printed and applied (label-over) by @Gear
Original chips:
ND frac = AS snapper
$1 = ES $1
$5 = Casablanca $100
$20 = ES T25 secondary
$100= PCA $100 secondary

:)
 
Non-trolling question:
So in order to qualify for any specific category, such as Hotstamp, does the entire lineup have to qualify? As opposed to just one aspect?
Example: one Hotstamp chip in a lineup of inlaid chips only qualifies for the Open category?

Citing: ceramic with MSK plaques.
 
markleteenie said:
Non-trolling question:
So in order to qualify for any specific category, such as Hotstamp, does the entire lineup have to qualify? As opposed to just one aspect?
Example: one Hotstamp chip in a lineup of inlaid chips only qualifies for the Open category?

Citing: ceramic with MSK plaques.
Click to expand...

I think that's a ceramic hybrid set, but having those MSK plaques gives that set an unfair advantage against other c/h sets. So I put it inot the Open Class.

I'm not trying to create any hard and fast rules... just trying to be fair to all sets.
 
WedgeRock said:
I think that's a ceramic hybrid set, but having those MSK plaques gives that set an unfair advantage against other c/h sets. So I put it inot the Open Class.

I'm not trying to create any hard and fast rules... just trying to be fair to all sets.
Click to expand...
I see your point and agree with your above ruling.

I know this is all for fun, but am wondering about how some things get ruled.

Well I'm wondering about this inevitable situation: a cash set with hotstamp fracs and inlaid $1+ vs a fully hotstamp tournament set.

Also another question I had: if a set has one actual casino chip in the lineup, does it get disqualified as a relabel? I think no, but I can see the argument either way.
Citing: @WhiteMamba1646 's Flamingo solids set.
 
I sort of agree, as the plaques are a fundamental part of the set, that's why i let somebody else decide. I hope there are a few more entrants in the open category before this is over though. :)
 
Mr Winberg said:
One way would be to randomize the whole bracket, then repeat the following two steps until done:

1) Find a person with more sets on a side than there should be (e.g. a person with two sets total having two sets on one half, or 3-4 sets total having 3 on one side, etc)
2) Randomized a set on the other side of the bracket that you can swap with. If the selected person would end up with too many sets on that side if swapped, then he/she is not eligible to swap and you need to pick another.

If someone has 3 or more sets, the two on the same side should not be on the same quarter, and the steps above can be repeated but restricted to that side of the bracket. 5 or more sets and two should not be on the same eighth, etc...

There might be a smarter way, but this greedy algorithm should solve it without too much extra work. Especially since it's you who is doing the work ;)
Click to expand...

If I enter a set I’d like to be able to influence which competitors are in my bracket as well please.
 
markleteenie said:
I see your point and agree with your above ruling.

I know this is all for fun, but am wondering about how some things get ruled.

Well I'm wondering about this inevitable situation: a cash set with hotstamp fracs and inlaid $1+ vs a fully hotstamp tournament set.

Also another question I had: if a set has one actual casino chip in the lineup, does it get disqualified as a relabel? I think no, but I can see the argument either way.
Citing: @WhiteMamba1646 's Flamingo solids set.
Click to expand...
So again, case-by-case basis. If an inlaid set has a hotstamp frac, its probably still an inlaid set. If a relabel set uses a live chip without re-labeling, its probably still a relabel. Unless something about the different chip gives that set an unfair advantage in a class.

And FWIW, if @HMK or anyone else disagrees with these decisions on-the-fly, post 'em up... I'll listen, and if you make a compelling point, I'll move them. Its supposed to be fun, but I don't want to hamper anyone because of my arbitrary decisions...
 
I can’t handle stuff like this, because I have stupid strong, unchangeable opinions about chips. For example, I don’t believe relabels should be allowed to exist, let alone be celebrated.
Good luck, all.
 
BonScot said:
I’ll enter my “Parris Luxury Resort & Casino” set. There’s no interesting story behind this other than a crappy pun on my surname. Anyway here’s some pics...
Click to expand...
I searched for a pron thread for these chips but didn't find one... Did you put up a post when you received these? If so, link?
 
WedgeRock said:
I think that's a ceramic hybrid set, but having those MSK plaques gives that set an unfair advantage against other c/h sets. So I put it inot the Open Class.

I'm not trying to create any hard and fast rules... just trying to be fair to all sets.
Click to expand...
One way could be to allow the 4 hybrid denoms in the ceramic hybrid class, and the whole set with plaques and all in the open class. And in case nobody has nominated it, I'd like to nominate @HMK tournament set to whichever class it may be entered. :)
 
Mr Winberg said:
One way could be to allow the 4 hybrid denoms in the ceramic hybrid class, and the whole set with plaques and all in the open class. And in case nobody has nominated it, I'd like to nominate @HMK tournament set to whichever class it may be entered. :)
Click to expand...

Doesn't seem fair to put the same set in two classes. Plus, this:

WedgeRock said:
In addition to the BOCY bracket, each chipset has the option of entering one additional "class" bracket.
Click to expand...
 
Sorry, I mixed up the open class with the BOCY bracket. Yes, I completely agree, just one class per set!
 
If it's BOCCY (crucial word: Custom), I don't think relabels should run in the main category ('cause the thread is titled "2020 CUSTOM set of the year").
If it's just BOCY, relabels can run in the main category too.
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account and join our community. It's easy!

Register

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Similar threads

JMC9389
  • Sticky
Best Fully Custom Set of 2023 Stump Thread
2
Replies
41
Views
2K
cpac54
cpac54
JMC9389
  • Locked
  • Poll
Best Relabel Chipset of 2022: Final, Bullenrunde vs. The Rabbit Hole
Replies
14
Views
837
Fran
Fran
Nuhockey
Giveaway Giveaway for the Women of the PCF
2
Replies
32
Views
1K
abby99
abby99
TX_Golf_N_Poker
2024 PCF March Madness Bracket Pool
2 3
Replies
80
Views
1K
TX_Golf_N_Poker
TX_Golf_N_Poker
MarquetteMonkey
2024 Hall of Fame Stump Thread
Replies
28
Views
1K
wonderpuddle
wonderpuddle
Back
Top Bottom