2018 Custom Chip HOF Thread (1 Viewer)

[Mr Tree]

The committee has gathered and begun deliberating candidates for the 2018 custom chip HOF. This thread is your chance to make your voice heard! While we already have initial lists going we will also review any eligible set put forward in this thread. If you have an opinion this is your place to give it, and please post pr0n as well!

Custom sets where the initial pr0n was put forward on or after 12/01/2016 are not eligible for the 2018 class. This group includes, but is not limited to:

The H Club
The Bicycle Shack
Aurora Club Hotstamos
The Club House
Harrow Club
Rosie's Bayou
Three Ring Circus
Lucky Buddha Club
The Breezeway
Nirvana Lounge
Decarlo Cardroom
Atlantic Club
The Metronome
Poco After Dark
Siam Imperia
Happy Valley Poker Club
Bourbon Basement

Also Contreras Landa is not eligible this year due to having been voted on for three consecutive years prior.

Thank you everyone and look for voting to happen in early January!

 

[superchromix]

Cool. Can you please post a link to the list of past HOF winners, and give more information about eligibility? For example, sets such as Colony club, Black cat club, Capitol room - are they still eligible?
thanks

 

[Poker Zombie]

Cool. Can you please post a link to the list of past HOF winners, and give more information about eligibility? For example, sets such as Colony club, Black cat club, Capitol room - are they still eligible?
thanks

https://www.pokerchipforum.com/resources/categories/hall-of-fame.6/

 

[Mr Tree]

Cool. Can you please post a link to the list of past HOF winners, and give more information about eligibility? For example, sets such as Colony club, Black cat club, Capitol room - are they still eligible?
thanks

The sets already in the HOF can be found in the resource section

https://www.pokerchipforum.com/resources/categories/hall-of-fame.6/

There are currently 16 HOF sets
The Black Cat Club (original)
The Boulevard
The Cedar Room (BCC)
Chateau De Noix (original)
Colony Club
Club Courage Twin Spires Cash
Duy’s Palace
The Hitching Post (cash)
Hungry Frog (tournament)
The Iron Bank
The Lady Luck Club
Le Boudoir
Silver Dust Casino
Suicide Queens
Three Putt Poker (cash)
Truman’s House

All custom sets are eligible for inclusion with two exceptions. There is a one year cool off period before a new set is eligible. Pr0n must have been posted before 12/01/2016 for eligibility this year.

Also Contrereras Landa is on a one year hiatus period as it has been voted for three consecutive years without making it in.

 

[Jeff]

In the op, you have the eligibility date as 12/1/17. Don’t you mean 12/1/16 if you are requiring a 1 year cooling off period?

 

[Mr Tree]

In the op, you have the eligibility date as 12/1/17. Don’t you mean 12/1/16 if you are requiring a 1 year cooling off period?

Sorry yes!

 

[dickzapper]

Aurora Club Hotstamos? Did AKChip make a John Stamos tribute set?

I vote for that one, then.

 

[Toby]

@72o's glorious Knollwoods!

 

[krafticus]

Edited.... I just learned how to read

 

[CraigT78]

Ah... the HoF threads - the only place with more bickering and opinions than a Chip Room sales thread

I'll see myself out......

 

[superchromix]

The committee has gathered and begun deliberating candidates for the 2018 custom chip HOF. This thread is your chance to make your voice heard! While we already have initial lists going we will also review any eligible set put forward in this thread. If you have an opinion this is your place to give it, and please post pr0n as well!

Custom sets where the initial pr0n was put forward on or after 12/01/2016 are not eligible for the 2018 class. This group includes, but is not limited to:

The H Club
The Bicycle Shack
Aurora Club Hotstamos
The Club House
Harrow Club
Rosie's Bayou
Three Ring Circus
Lucky Buddha Club
The Breezeway
Nirvana Lounge
Decarlo Cardroom
Atlantic Club
The Metronome
Poco After Dark
Siam Imperia
Happy Valley Poker Club
Bourbon Basement

Also Contreras Landa is not eligible this year due to having been voted on for three consecutive years prior.

Thank you everyone and look for voting to happen in early January!

Just FYI, the first time I read this post, I understood that ONLY the sets in this list were eligible.

Might be better to list eligible sets, rather than ineligible ones.

 

[WedgeRock]

That's a lot of eligible sets...

 

[Mr Tree]

Just FYI, the first time I read this post, I understood that ONLY the sets in this list were eligible.

Might be better to list eligible sets, rather than ineligible ones.

Lol, that we be about 10,000 sets.

 

[Rhodeman77]

Will there be 3 sets added to the HOF again?

 

[superchromix]

Lol, that we be about 10,000 sets.

don't see any problem there

 

[CraigT78]

Lol, that we be about 10,000 sets.

don't see any problem there

Also include pr0n of each set!

 

[Toby]

@Chippy McChiperson's Bill's Haus of Bluff!

 

[Toby]

@Mr Tree do you still have last year's HOF exclusion list, the pr0n posted within the date range sets?

 

[GIANTDustySquid]

DAMN I want to be involved in this next year

 

[Mr Tree]

@Mr Tree do you still have last year's HOF exclusion list, the pr0n posted within the date range sets?

Ask and ye shall receive...

Aurora Club (cash and tournament)
Bill's Haus of Bluff
Black Cat Club (MD50 cash)
Boardwalk Card Club
Bordeaux Lounge
Broken Bell (cash and tournament)
Bubb's Poker Room
Casino Royale
Circle Dedale
Chateaux de Noix v 2.0 (cash and tournament)
Circle HP hot stamps
Fat Tire tournament
Gentleman Jack's Card Room
Harlequin Card Room
Hrutar
Knollwoods
Montreaux
Paymaster
Pillage & Plunder
Soapy's Parlor
Sunset
The Armory (cash)
The Music Shack
Varsity Poker
Windy Crest Poker

 

[Toby]

Ask and ye shall receive...

Aurora Club (cash and tournament)
Bill's Haus of Bluff
Black Cat Club (MD50 cash)
Boardwalk Card Club
Bordeaux Lounge
Broken Bell (cash and tournament)
Bubb's Poker Room
Casino Royale
Circle Dedale
Chateaux de Noix v 2.0 (cash and tournament)
Circle HP hot stamps
Fat Tire tournament
Gentleman Jack's Card Room
Harlequin Card Room
Hrutar
Knollwoods
Montreaux
Paymaster
Pillage & Plunder
Soapy's Parlor
Sunset
The Armory (cash)
The Music Shack
Varsity Poker
Windy Crest Poker

What happens with Pillage and Plunder, which has had addons?

I'd like to nominate but I'm not sure what I'm nominating!

 

[upNdown]

@Chippy McChiperson's Bill's Haus of Pubic Lice!

Do nominations need to be seconded or thirded?
It's tough to pick a #1 favorite all time custom set, but I could probably narrow it down to five, and this one is there.

 

[flipupchipup]

Capital Room - BCC Greek Mold

 

[Toby]

@H|Q's Harlequin Card Room!

^EDIT: here they are!

I'd post a pic of the awesome bounty/seating chips...

...but is it in-play/denominated chips only?

Can't remember the rule!

I'm making @Mr Tree earn his salary this year!

 

[Mr Tree]

Do nominations need to be seconded or thirded?
It's tough to pick a #1 favorite all time custom set, but I could probably narrow it down to five, and this one is there.

The actual nominations come from the committee. This is just to stump for sets you think the committee should be including.

 

[Mr Tree]

@H|Q's Harlequin Card Room!

I'd post a pic of the awesome bounty/seating chips...

...but is it in-play/denominated chips only?

Can't remember the rule!

I'm making @Mr Tree earn his salary this year!

Any chip that is demonstrably part of a set and serves a purpose within the set counts as being a part.

This originally came up because of the excellent Redbelly bounty chip.

 

[upNdown]

The actual nominations come from the committee. This is just to stump for sets you think the committee should be including.

Stump stump

 

[Mr Tree]

What happens with Pillage and Plunder, which has had addons?

I'd like to nominate but I'm not sure what I'm nominating!

Date is by original pr0n posting. The add ins count.

 

[Irish]

Stumping for gcrissman's Steel City Club (pic from Toby's media album):

 

[Poker Zombie]

Do nominations need to be seconded or thirded?
It's tough to pick a #1 favorite all time custom set, but I could probably narrow it down to five, and this one is there.

Committee gets reminders here - A committee of 5 could easily overlook a great set. Recent sets are far more memorable and are unlikely to be missed by the committee, but the older sets risk being lost to the winds of time. This thread helps to fill in those cracks, and make the HoF as great as it can be.