markleteenie
4 of a Kind
+1 to this, or is it +100?The biggest problem with the rating scale, to me, is the relative point values. RHC is not -1 in my book. It's more like -100.
Meaning, the rest of the categories become irrelevant.
edit: OK, maybe that's a little harsh. It's more just a commentary that I don't think the categories are equivalent. And that every person probably weighs each category very differently.
I don't believe all categories are weighted equally. Also, I don't believe that the presence of IHC necessarily adds to the (or rather my) "scorecard."
Another example: above average spot/color choices , but if it's a shitshow, make for great relabel project chips and not a cohesive lineup.