How did I know you'd weigh in,
@BGinGA? Did you bring
@Gobbs? I know it's a hot button with him too from back in the HPT days.
What limits are you playing where the aggregate of all winners is $300-$600? And why are your dealers making as much or more than your winning players (assuming the big winner is 25% to 50% of the aggregate table win)? That's insane.
Each time I play, I give 10% to one of my family members (wife or kids) depending on which card cover I'm using. And I tip out the house too for hosting. Add another 10% to the dealer and now I'm taking home 70¢ on the dollar and all losses are on me. At our stakes and with our player pool (which range from competent to excellent at dealing for the most part), I'll save that 10%.
This is indisputable, however.
@Marc Hedrick is am excellent dealer. (I think I first met you when you dealt an Ypsi game to earn enough tips to buyin.) Anyway, the game definitely moves smoother when Marc has the deck.
Maybe that's the big difference. No one in our group is a poor dealer. Or maybe we define "poor dealer" differently.