Official PCF Whisk(e)y Thread (52 Viewers)
- Thread starter jbutler
- Start date
Big Jilm
4 of a Kind
2nd neck pour of the day. Hmmmmmm, this is really interesting. Get a little oak and rye on the nose, palate is really fruity, then the long finish slaps your face with an explosion of rye flavor. This is really unique.
FDLmold
Royal Flush
That good, eh? I have the double oak, I will open it some day. I might have to try this one too.
Yeah I’m curious to know how they compare
Big Jilm
4 of a Kind
Likewise.....I will open the double oak after this one
Dodger
Flush
Not a bad little sipper.
It's been an all-scotch weekend, mostly Balvenie and Glemorangie on Friday/Saturday, but after killing those bottles it was time to try something new (for me). Clynelish 14.
Very light orange peel / citrus on the nose. Citrus leads on the palatte but dries out very quickly, peppery brine notes come to play, with just a very slight hint of peat. Peppery/spicy but super smooth! Finishes with the brine kicking up a notch and a slighlty bitter tone (lemon?) coming up as it fades. Really interesting dram and very tasty, especially for the price
Very light orange peel / citrus on the nose. Citrus leads on the palatte but dries out very quickly, peppery brine notes come to play, with just a very slight hint of peat. Peppery/spicy but super smooth! Finishes with the brine kicking up a notch and a slighlty bitter tone (lemon?) coming up as it fades. Really interesting dram and very tasty, especially for the price
Big Jilm
4 of a Kind
Last taste tonight. Decided to keep it ryel
Bottle #121 of 191. Bottled 2/2/21. 114.6 proof.
Bottle #121 of 191. Bottled 2/2/21. 114.6 proof.
Big Jilm
4 of a Kind
Which batch? Not 16 I believe..
14 maybe?
Big Jilm
4 of a Kind
Confirmed. WELL DONE!!
Yeah, that was on the short list for #3, but by that time our food had arrived, and I'd rather the whiskey be center stage than to drink it while eating.
It's been an all-scotch weekend, mostly Balvenie and Glemorangie on Friday/Saturday, but after killing those bottles it was time to try something new (for me). Clynelish 14.
View attachment 775885
Very light orange peel / citrus on the nose. Citrus leads on the palatte but dries out very quickly, peppery brine notes come to play, with just a very slight hint of peat. Peppery/spicy but super smooth! Finishes with the brine kicking up a notch and a slighlty bitter tone (lemon?) coming up as it fades. Really interesting dram and very tasty, especially for the price
This is one of my favorites. Honestly I could drink this everyday
Big Jilm
4 of a Kind
Snap buy at $35, $40 max for me. At $50 I'd likely pass, there are better offerings in that range.
gopherblue
Straight Flush
But not in the UK. That is a very good price there. Best I've seen in the UK is 35 quid.
It's all relative to what else you can get for £37.
Dodger
Flush
Don’t know the quality of others going in that price range in the UK. But, if you’ve never had it before, give it a go and determine for yourself.
Forty4
Full House
Anyone got thoughts on the Blackened Willett collaboration?
Thanks for the advice, gents.
Might pull the trigger next time, but decided to put the money towards a hefty slab of cow tonight instead, as opposed to eagle...
The good news is that I found a batch 16. The bad news is that my honey hole raised their price. No longer just above retail. Now $111 with tax.
Billy Baroo
Flush
Latest store pick! Might need to grab another before they’re gone.
Terrible price. If you want your $111 back hit me upThe good news is that I found a batch 16. The bad news is that my honey hole raised their price. No longer just above retail. Now $111 with tax.
View attachment 777358
I’d send you a sample, but someone has not returned my bottles.
This one has opened up a bit, but I don’t think it’s worth the premium over the small batch. Maybe it’s just my bottle. It’s pretty good, but not worth the price difference.
I don’t have the store pick but I like the standard. I also have this which I havent cracked yet
Last edited:
Klobberer
Full House
I've heard it's good, but very expensive.
Big Jilm
4 of a Kind
The good news is that I found a batch 16. The bad news is that my honey hole raised their price. No longer just above retail. Now $111 with tax.
View attachment 777358
Ouch bro! That is one of the reasons you need to relocate your family to Oregon. Mine was $49.95 out the door. (plus we could hang out, play poker, drink whiskey and all, just sayin....)
BruceWayne
Flush
Looking forward to the KC SBR in particular
Create an account or login to comment
You must be a member in order to leave a comment
Create account
Create an account and join our community. It's easy!
Log in
Already have an account? Log in here.
