Is Chili a Soup? (2 Viewers)

[gopherblue]

We all know that it is well-settled that a hotdog sandwich is, in fact, a sandwich (except for those who refuse to agree). However, as it is now officially autumn, and along with it, cooler weather is upon us, a fella’s thoughts turn to more important matters…like soup.

So, it occurs to me: is chili a soup?

 

[BPTDirector]

Yes /thread

 

[Frogzilla]

Always see it in the soup section of the menu. I say yes

 

[chippitydoodah]

It's more of a stew and typically eaten as a meal all by itself.

 

[buffalojim]

It's more of a stew

Ding

 

[NotRealNameNoSir]

It's more of a stew and typically eaten as a meal all by itself.

I don't disagree with the stew premise, but this slander that soup isn't a meal by itself is preposterous. Hearty chicken noodle needs no bedfellows.

 

[buffalojim]

I don't disagree with the stew premise, but this slander that soup isn't a meal by itself is preposterous. Hearty chicken noodle needs no bedfellows.

Also ding

 

[TheBigTater]

Is that with or without beans...... asking for the sane people.....

 

[Hot Nuts]

 

[Pinkdan]

 

[buffalojim]

I see the civility has gone right out the window. Enjoy fellas.

 

[NotRealNameNoSir]

View attachment 1569148

 

[raynmanas]

It's more of a stew and typically eaten as a meal all by itself.

you can turn any stew into a soup by adding liquid. so the question is, where is the cutoff?

 

[NotRealNameNoSir]

you can turn any stew into a soup by adding liquid. so the question is, where is the cutoff?

My friends and I had a knock down drag-em-out argument over this spanning a day at the lake, it came down to ratios and constituents and intention when cooking. Ended with a buddy calling another a "riceless peasant", saving that one for a rainy day.

 

[Budha]

After much internal debate and extensive research I have concluded chili is a stew.

Although I agree a hearty chicken noodle is both delicious and can be a meal, you cannot put chicken noodle on a 1). Hotdog, 2). Nachos, 3). Hamburger, 4). Burrito (or in), 5). Spaghetti (for our Cincinnati folks).

You can put beef stew over mashed potatoes or over a biscuit. (Therefore also not a “soup”)

I therefore conclude based on the preponderance of evidence that chili must be a stew (that can also be a topping).

 

[BPTDirector]

Chili soup > Chili stew

 

[buffalojim]

After much internal debate and extensive research I have concluded chili is a stew.

Although I agree a hearty chicken noodle is both delicious and can be a meal, you cannot put chicken noodle on a 1). Hotdog, 2). Nachos, 3). Hamburger, 4). Burrito (or in), 5). Spaghetti (for our Cincinnati folks).

You can put beef stew over mashed potatoes or over a biscuit. (Therefore also not a “soup”)

I therefore conclude based on the preponderance of evidence that chili must be a stew (that can also be a topping).

 

[BPTDirector]

After much internal debate and extensive research I have concluded chili is a stew.

Although I agree a hearty chicken noodle is both delicious and can be a meal, you cannot put chicken noodle on a 1). Hotdog, 2). Nachos, 3). Hamburger, 4). Burrito (or in), 5). Spaghetti (for our Cincinnati folks).

You can put beef stew over mashed potatoes or over a biscuit. (Therefore also not a “soup”)

I therefore conclude based on the preponderance of evidence that chili must be a stew (that can also be a topping).

By this definition cheese is a stew.

 

[NotRealNameNoSir]

Chili soup > Chili stew

I got the runs just reading this.

 

[Budha]

By this definition cheese is a stew.

 

[BPTDirector]

I submit the soup is served in a bowl and stew on a plate. Observe, this chili was crowned world champion and is the best BOWL of red in my home town.

 

[RocAFella1]

Is a chili cheese dog - a soup and a sandwich?

 

[BPTDirector]

It’s a meal unto itself with or without cheese where I’m from.

 

[DrStrange]

Poorly made chili is obviously a soup -=- DrStrange

 

[BPTDirector]

Poorly made chili is obviously a soup -=- DrStrange

Another matter of opinion that will never be settled.

 

[chippitydoodah]

To some of you heathens, this is chili soup on a hotdog sandwich. Sickening.

 

[Tonysquander]

As the only state that has declared chili con carne its official dish, I think Texas' declaration that chili is a stew is binding on this debate. The fact non-Texans have adulterated the chili pepper w/ meat concept by watering it down so their pansy palates can handle 15% of the chili's power carries no weight whatsoever.

 

[BPTDirector]

Come to Springfield, Illinois and have a bowl of Firebrand chili, then talk to me.

 

[chippitydoodah]

What else could I have for lunch today but Chili Dogs

 

[Josh Kifer]