Jonesey07
Full House
Note app on my phone. Haha
Official PCF Whisk(e)y Thread (44 Viewers)
- Thread starter jbutler
- Start date
Indyscammer
Flush
Trend?
Haven’t opened mine yet. Maybe tonight?
Big Jilm
4 of a Kind
LFG!!!
gopherblue
Straight Flush
Retail flex.
Indyscammer
Flush
First and ten do it again!
gopherblue
Straight Flush
I might need to open my BBNAGB bottle?
Fine guys. I’ll pop mine while I prep my sermon for tomorrow. Lol
the nose is so fantastic
Big Jilm
4 of a Kind
Definitely get the oaky toasted marshmallow on the nose.
The raisin note is absolutely there on the palate, caramel too.
Have to agree with the sweet cocoa finish too.
Nice job guys. A nice bottle of whiskey!
The raisin note is absolutely there on the palate, caramel too.
Have to agree with the sweet cocoa finish too.
Nice job guys. A nice bottle of whiskey!
Indyscammer
Flush
Best New Riff I've had. Anyone drink it regularly?
While not regular I have had their BiB and it is good, but our private selection blows it away.
FDLmold
Royal Flush
I've got a New Riff bourbon SB, rye SB, balboa rye, and malted rye. I like all of them, balboa probably the least. I imagine if I had gotten in on this group buy, that bottle might have beaten them all.
Indyscammer
Flush
The Malted 6 year is unique and great. Not the same as the Bourbon though. So good. New Riff will become a player. I would love an old New Riff - 10, 12 year? Coming in 24 or 26!
LabMonkey
Flush
Late night out west. Great selection guys!
I got up really early this morning and headed to a bottle draft run by my favorite store.
Heaven Hill 17yr went first.
Then Weller CYPB.
Then Weller Full Proof.
Then Old Forester Birthday Bourbon 2021.
Then Willett 8yr bourbon.
With the 6th pick in the 2022 whiskey bottle draft, @Saoliver selects:
Old Forester 150th Anniversary Batch 2! I had it #3 in my pre-draft ranking, so was very happy that it fell to #6.
Got a store pick Knob Creek Rye too.
Heaven Hill 17yr went first.
Then Weller CYPB.
Then Weller Full Proof.
Then Old Forester Birthday Bourbon 2021.
Then Willett 8yr bourbon.
With the 6th pick in the 2022 whiskey bottle draft, @Saoliver selects:
Old Forester 150th Anniversary Batch 2! I had it #3 in my pre-draft ranking, so was very happy that it fell to #6.
Got a store pick Knob Creek Rye too.
BruceWayne
Flush
I got up really early this morning and headed to a bottle draft run by my favorite store.
View attachment 985080View attachment 985081View attachment 985082
Heaven Hill 17yr went first.
Then Weller CYPB.
Then Weller Full Proof.
Then Old Forester Birthday Bourbon 2021.
Then Willett 8yr bourbon.
With the 6th pick in the 2022 whiskey bottle draft, @Saoliver selects:
Old Forester 150th Anniversary Batch 2! I had it #3 in my pre-draft ranking, so was very happy that it fell to #6.
Got a store pick Knob Creek Rye too.
View attachment 985083
https://getyarn.io/yarn-clip/c3f38cf8-64b8-4385-aaf1-3bba38a7eb7c
FDLmold
Royal Flush
Which Little Book was that? I'd have put it above some of the Weller if it was the right chapter. Surprised Coy Hill was outside the top 6. I'd have taken EHT barrel proof over Weller FP.I got up really early this morning and headed to a bottle draft run by my favorite store.
Heaven Hill 17yr went first.
Then Weller CYPB.
Then Weller Full Proof.
Then Old Forester Birthday Bourbon 2021.
Then Willett 8yr bourbon.
With the 6th pick in the 2022 whiskey bottle draft, @Saoliver selects:
Old Forester 150th Anniversary Batch 2! I had it #3 in my pre-draft ranking, so was very happy that it fell to #6.
Got a store pick Knob Creek Rye too.
Nice acquisition.
Little book chapter 5. I already have 2 of them. I also have a Coy Hill. And 2 EHT Barrel Proofs.
Here was my personal ranking.
| 1 | Old Forester B'day 2021 104p |
| 2 | Heaven Hill 17yr |
| 3 | Old Forester 150th Annv 126.4p |
| 4 | Willett 8yr BBN 129.4p |
| 5 | Suntory Hibiki 21y |
| 6 | Old Fitz 14yr |
| 7 | EH Taylor Barrel Proof |
| 7 | EH Taylor Barrel Proof |
| 8 | Weller CYPB |
| 9 | Willett 6yr RYE 110.2p |
| 10 | HD Bootleg vol III 13y 121.1p |
| 11 | Rock Hill Farms |
| 12 | Jack Daniels Coy Hill |
| 13 | Old Forester SB Rye 127.4p |
| 14 | WT Masters Keep One 101p |
| 15 | EH Taylor Rye |
| 16 | Michters 10y Rye 2021 |
| 17 | Michters 10y Rye 2022 |
| 18 | Stagg Batch 18 |
| 19 | Stagg jr Batch 14 130.2p |
| 20 | Stagg jr Batch 17 128.7p |
| 21 | Weller Full Proof |
| 21 | Weller Full Proof |
| 22 | Weller 12y |
| 22 | Weller 12y |
| 23 | Angels Envy Cask Str 2021 |
| 24 | Blood Oath #8 |
| 25 | HW Midwinter Night Act 9 Sc 2 |
| 26 | Michters Toasted BBN |
| 27 | Elmer T Lee |
| 27 | Elmer T Lee |
| 28 | Bombergers 2020 108p |
| 29 | Little Book 2021 116.8p |
| 30 | Elijah Craig 18y |
| 31 | Bookers 21-4 Noe Stranger Batch |
| 32 | WB Saffell 107p |
| 33 | EH Taylor Small Batch |
Klobberer
Full House
What were the prices?Little book chapter 5. I already have 2 of them. I also have a Coy Hill. And 2 EHT Barrel Proofs.
Here was my personal ranking.
1 Old Forester B'day 2021 104p 2 Heaven Hill 17yr 3 Old Forester 150th Annv 126.4p 4 Willett 8yr BBN 129.4p 5 Suntory Hibiki 21y 6 Old Fitz 14yr 7 EH Taylor Barrel Proof 7 EH Taylor Barrel Proof 8 Weller CYPB 9 Willett 6yr RYE 110.2p 10 HD Bootleg vol III 13y 121.1p 11 Rock Hill Farms 12 Jack Daniels Coy Hill 13 Old Forester SB Rye 127.4p 14 WT Masters Keep One 101p 15 EH Taylor Rye 16 Michters 10y Rye 2021 17 Michters 10y Rye 2022 18 Stagg Batch 18 19 Stagg jr Batch 14 130.2p 20 Stagg jr Batch 17 128.7p 21 Weller Full Proof 21 Weller Full Proof 22 Weller 12y 22 Weller 12y 23 Angels Envy Cask Str 2021 24 Blood Oath #8 25 HW Midwinter Night Act 9 Sc 2 26 Michters Toasted BBN 27 Elmer T Lee 27 Elmer T Lee 28 Bombergers 2020 108p 29 Little Book 2021 116.8p 30 Elijah Craig 18y 31 Bookers 21-4 Noe Stranger Batch 32 WB Saffell 107p 33 EH Taylor Small Batch
I promised not to tell. But they weren’t MSRP. But also not secondary.
My bottle was $279.
Billy Baroo
Flush
These mini JD’s are pretty cool. The juice in them is really good!
BlueChipSpecial
Straight
Breaking into the Donkey Juice - sharing a pour with the wife.
How you know you found a keeper: when she is as excited to try new whiskeys as you are!
Loving this bottle! Nice choice, Gents!
gopherblue
Straight Flush
I mostly agree with this ranking. ;-)Little book chapter 5. I already have 2 of them. I also have a Coy Hill. And 2 EHT Barrel Proofs.
Here was my personal ranking.
1 Old Forester B'day 2021 104p 2 Heaven Hill 17yr 3 Old Forester 150th Annv 126.4p 4 Willett 8yr BBN 129.4p 5 Suntory Hibiki 21y 6 Old Fitz 14yr 7 EH Taylor Barrel Proof 7 EH Taylor Barrel Proof 8 Weller CYPB 9 Willett 6yr RYE 110.2p 10 HD Bootleg vol III 13y 121.1p 11 Rock Hill Farms 12 Jack Daniels Coy Hill 13 Old Forester SB Rye 127.4p 14 WT Masters Keep One 101p 15 EH Taylor Rye 16 Michters 10y Rye 2021 17 Michters 10y Rye 2022 18 Stagg Batch 18 19 Stagg jr Batch 14 130.2p 20 Stagg jr Batch 17 128.7p 21 Weller Full Proof 21 Weller Full Proof 22 Weller 12y 22 Weller 12y 23 Angels Envy Cask Str 2021 24 Blood Oath #8 25 HW Midwinter Night Act 9 Sc 2 26 Michters Toasted BBN 27 Elmer T Lee 27 Elmer T Lee 28 Bombergers 2020 108p 29 Little Book 2021 116.8p 30 Elijah Craig 18y 31 Bookers 21-4 Noe Stranger Batch 32 WB Saffell 107p 33 EH Taylor Small Batch
Last edited:
Getting ready for Oktoberfest. And found out today my local whiskey club will be having a barrel pick Weller 107 for this month. Celebrating with steaks and a pour. Cheers!
Poker Zombie
Royal Flush
I completely agree, and I am no longer a JD fan. Jack (Black label) was my non-scotch whisky of choice in college, and always have some in the bar for non-discriminating guests. I used to use it for bourbon sauces and BBQ, but have found a better cooking flavor in Makers.
These little bottles (when I can find them) have me reconsidering visiting the local distillery.
Create an account or login to comment
You must be a member in order to leave a comment
Create account
Create an account and join our community. It's easy!
Log in
Already have an account? Log in here.
