Help me pick a Frac - RHC set (7 Viewers)

[roughrabbit]

HELP WANTED:

Stuck in a fit of analysis paralysis. Can't decide on a frac between my south bend $1s and solid goldstrike roulettes. Each have their pros and cons listed below and I can't decide what to go with. Any input is appreciated
South bend:
Pro - able to add on, easier relabel, fun edge spots, have all the chips I want
Cons - slightly more worn but fits the set well, edge spots are similar to 100 and share the same neon green spot (I'm not sure if the $100 and .25 will ever be on the table at the same time)
Solid roulette:
Pro - sharp, bright, fits set well too
Cons - difficult to relabel (getting the hang of it), still looking for 40 more chips.

Each chip has one picture taken under househokf lighting and one under led.

 

[suchj0sh]

I can tell you from experience that the GS roulettes are miserable to murder, so that should definitely be a serious consideration.

 

[roughrabbit]

I can tell you from experience that the GS roulettes are miserable to murder, so that should definitely be a serious consideration.

Valid point, I was going to overlabel but then liked the look of a relabel more which helped cause this issue.

 

[TheJestyr]

Personally I like solid fracs…feels more “coin-ish” to me. I also like the spot progression of the solids better in your lineup. But I’m not the one who’d have to find 40 more, then murder and relabel them.

 

[btbmason]

Depending on how crazy you are, I believe the GS roulettes are leaded or semi-leaded, which may lead to different sound/feel than the remainder of the set if those are not leaded chips.

If that isn’t an issue I like the solids a lot better with the lineup. The South Bend $1 is a great chip but ends up outshining the rest. Though if you’re highlighting the frac, not a terrible idea either.

Also suggest posting a photo with the chip faces to get a good look at the spots from the top next to each other.

Nice looking set either way!

 

[roughrabbit]

Depending on how crazy you are, I believe the GS roulettes are leaded or semi-leaded, which may lead to different sound/feel than the remainder of the set if those are not leaded chips.

If that isn’t an issue I like the solids a lot better with the lineup. The South Bend $1 is a great chip but ends up outshining the rest. Though if you’re highlighting the frac, not a terrible idea either.

Also suggest posting a photo with the chip faces to get a good look at the spots from the top next to each other.

Nice looking set either way!

They are leaded and mint, so they would feel a little different than the rest of the set.

 

[reim]

South Bend would be my choice

 

[GreatWhiteDope]

I'm with @TheJestyr, I prefer a solid frac.

 

[SixSeven]

I like the South Bend $1's. The spots are a nice fit with the other denom spots.

 

[CardRally]

Nice set!
Judging strictly on the visual harmony of the set as a whole, I prefer the solid. For me it is not even close. The SB $1 being the only chip in the lineup with a 3 color edge spot really makes it stick out.