Yes, 100%. If one deck in a setup is not good, the entire setup is worthless. I also do not think you should have “mixed” sets with different inlays, either, so take my opinion with that in mind.
Right now, I would play with post it notes that the host's kid drew pictures on....but that's another thread.
Typically, it's whatever two decks came in the same container. I am way not picky about cards as long as they are plastic, or at least somewhat new paper.