Official PCF Whisk(e)y Thread (37 Viewers)

Saoliver said:
Single Barrel Barrel Strength Rye.

I Love It GIF


View attachment 1277230
Click to expand...
Yes. I understand what you were saying it is. I just didn't know that it existed. Sounds like it's very hard to find and expensive. What's new...
 
BruceWayne said:
That'll do...

You're on quite a run lately!
Click to expand...
Fortunately poker has been good so I can cover it all :wtf: but yeah it's been a really good month or two of finding stuff.
TX_Golf_N_Poker said:
And what's this OF BS rye? I was unaware of that one. OF 100 is my favorite house rye for cocktails, and OF BS single barrel is an amazing bourbon. So now I guess I have a new bottle to chase. :rolleyes:
Click to expand...
It's fantastic. @Saoliver sent me a sample for Christmas '22 and it was #2 out of 11 for me. Hoping the whiskey run good continues and I can find a reasonably priced bottle.
 
natumes said:
Fortunately poker has been good so I can cover it all :wtf: but yeah it's been a really good month or two of finding stuff.

It's fantastic. @Saoliver sent me a sample for Christmas '22 and it was #2 out of 11 for me. Hoping the whiskey run good continues and I can find a reasonably priced bottle.
Click to expand...
What came in first? I just watched a video from Mash & Drum. He put the OF BS up against 4 other very solid ryes. It came in a very, very close second to JD SB BP. I can buy that at my local TW for $69. I've been hearing that both the Jack BPs were good, so I may have to try that one, since it's on the shelf.
 
TX_Golf_N_Poker said:
What came in first? I just watched a video from Mash & Drum. He put the OF BS up against 4 other very solid ryes. It came in a very, very close second to JD SB BP. I can buy that at my local TW for $69. I've been hearing that both the Jack BPs were good, so I may have to try that one, since it's on the shelf.
Click to expand...
If you love JD rye, stick to it. It’s great. But I prefer OF. It just hits so good.
 
TX_Golf_N_Poker said:
What came in first? I just watched a video from Mash & Drum. He put the OF BS up against 4 other very solid ryes. It came in a very, very close second to JD SB BP. I can buy that at my local TW for $69. I've been hearing that both the Jack BPs were good, so I may have to try that one, since it's on the shelf.
Click to expand...
EHT Rye for me. Handy in 3rd (going to be revisiting this vs EHT this week). I believe Barrell Seagrass Silver was 4th, and Smoke Wagon Malted Rye 5th. After that I don't remember, but there was Stellum, New Riff, Old Pepper, Obtanium, Alberta Premium, and I can't remember the last one in there. It was a great Christmas haha! I don't have a lot of selection for Rye locally so take my opinion with a grain of salt, before these I had only owned a bottle of Willet, High West, and regular Sazerac for Ryes.
 
natumes said:
EHT Rye for me. Handy in 3rd (going to be revisiting this vs EHT this week). I believe Barrell Seagrass Silver was 4th, and Smoke Wagon Malted Rye 5th. After that I don't remember, but there was Stellum, New Riff, Old Pepper, Obtanium, Alberta Premium, and I can't remember the last one in there. It was a great Christmas haha! I don't have a lot of selection for Rye locally so take my opinion with a grain of salt, before these I had only owned a bottle of Willet, High West, and regular Sazerac for Ryes.
Click to expand...
Santa Scotty was good to you. :LOL: :laugh:
 
B1 v B8
B1 nose- pepper, oak, char, proof
palette - oak, cinnamon, cocoa, nice finish
B8 nose - fruit, honey, floral
palette - sweet, good mouth feel, not complex char on
backend, medium finish
winner - B1
this one was close

B2 v B7
B2 Nose - Brown sugar, tabacco, red fruit
palette - tabacco, oak, nutmeg, nice finish, viscous
B7 nose - pepper, nutty, proof
palette - oak, pepper, cocoa, slightly bitter
winner - B2

bracket3.jpeg
 
wolfpack said:
I have decided to do another bracket challenge.

I am taking the top 32 whiskeys I have from last yearand I am doing a NCAA style blind bracket.

The competitors are
Bakers 13
redwood empire lost monarch cs
Elijah Craig c923
Little Book Chapter 7
New Riff Silver Grove
Larceny C923
Redwood empire Pipe Dream CS
4 Roses SBBS OESV 11year 112.6 teir 2
EH Taylor BP Batch 12
Stagg 23a
rock hill farms
John J Bowman SiB
old forester sib 100 ohlq#7047
Stagg 23b
Old Forester sbbp Wild Indian 131.5 J/2
Jack Daniels 10 year
Blue Note UCUF 122.7
Old Forester sbbp Bottom of the Barrel 130.2 k/4
stagg 23c
Larceny B523
Weller 107 OHLQ sib pick
russell reseve sib distillery pick
Jack Daniels 12 year
old forester sbbp john o's 2023 127.1 h/4
weller cypb
Old Forester 117 Bottled in Bond
larceny a123
Jack Daniels sbbp 130.5 (decanter)
New Riff Barrel Pick BBNAGBII
1792 Full Proof John o's Pick
Old Fitz 10 year
Bernheim c923

The bottles will be labeled A, B, C, D 1-8 by my wife and she will be doing the pours so I do not know what I am tasting

No bottles will be revealed until the bracket has been completed.
Place your bets


View attachment 1275797
Click to expand...
Hell of a lineup! You’re living the dream man
 
Saoliver said:
My lineups for when I’m wet again:

March 1st
Old Pepper FKO rye
Parker’s 10yr rye
Old Overholt 10yr rye
OF BS rye
Handy

March 2nd
Michter’s 10yr bourbon
James E Pepper Decanter
4R LE 2022
EHT BP
Blanton’s Gold
Click to expand...
What are you paying for the M10 bourbon? My favorite and I'm down to less than half a bottle...
 
DZPoker said:
1792 FP is still one of my favorites when considering price…so I’m going to go with the long shot here and put my money on:
1792 Full Proof John o's Pick!!

I don’t need to win…I just hope to make it past the first round LOL!!
Click to expand...
bold pick with this lineup
 
KidFromCleveland said:
So the bad news is that I didn’t cash in either of the two WSOP Cherokee events I played in this weekend (happy to have beat 1/2 the field in both though).
Good news is they have JD Barrel Proof lining the shelves in NC, so will be coming home with some conciliation prizes!!!
Click to expand...
Take advantage of that while you can! I have pretty much unlimited access right now to both the BP whiskey and rye in my neck of the woods of NC, but it hasn’t always been that way. There was a long drought for it from early 22 all the way up to about fall of 23. I certainly hope it stays readily available…they’re both favorites of mine! I stocked up on both just in case.
 
Billy Baroo said:
I agree…plastic cap Brown Forman ET BiB was fantastic especially when you factor in the price, but to me it’s not close to the same level as Alberta Premium Cask.
Click to expand...
There is a store by me that had Alberta for $41 a bottle. It wasn't my thing, so I passed on it. If anyone local to me wants one or 2, let me know and I can pick it up. @Highli99 @Cliff
 
krafticus said:
yeah. Again, not in my flavor profile. Thankfully, we have several options, right !!?!?!?! :)
Click to expand...

A friend said this to me about a decade or so ago. It has always stuck with me. "If we all liked the same thing, it would be a boring as place to live".

I love that shit. It is mostly unavailable around here. When I do find it. It is two to three times that price.
 
detroitdad said:
A friend said this to me about a decade or so ago. It has always stuck with me. "If we all liked the same thing, it would be a boring as place to live".

I love that shit. It is mostly unavailable around here. When I do find it. It is two to three times that price.
Click to expand...
I was paying anywhere between $70-80 a bottle for it when I first found it. My closest and most frequented ABC store put it on clearance last fall for $40 and I grabbed their last 3. Great price for sure but it also means they won’t order it anymore because apparently I was the only one buying it :ROFL: :ROFLMAO:
 
Billy Baroo said:
I was paying anywhere between $70-80 a bottle for it when I first found it. My closest and most frequented ABC store put it on clearance last fall for $40 and I grabbed their last 3. Great price for sure but it also means they won’t order it anymore because apparently I was the only one buying it :ROFL: :ROFLMAO:
Click to expand...

I didn't have a problem paying $75 a bottle for it. I just can't find it :( I love it. Every sip is like a circus in your mouth lol
 
krafticus said:
There is a store by me that had Alberta for $41 a bottle. It wasn't my thing, so I passed on it. If anyone local to me wants one or 2, let me know and I can pick it up. @Highli99 @Cliff
Click to expand...
Assuming it's the cask strength version (they do have a "regular" Alberta Premium), grab a bunch for @Cliff for old fashions lol.

It's available around here pretty regularly now, usually like $70. At $40 a pop I'd never have a non-Alberta old fashion again :D
 
Irish said:
Assuming it's the cask strength version (they do have a "regular" Alberta Premium), grab a bunch for @Cliff for old fashions lol.

It's available around here pretty regularly now, usually like $70. At $40 a pop I'd never have a non-Alberta old fashion again :D
Click to expand...
If you’re an old fashion fan, you have no idea what you’re missing if you haven’t had one made with the AP Cask! If you have, you know exactly what I’m talking about :cool
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account and join our community. It's easy!

Register

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Similar threads

warma
Help: whisk(e)y tasting at poker night
2 3 4
Replies
93
Views
4K
warma
warma
Back
Top Bottom