1. The chips were not going to be split at all. Bobb was interested in the photos.
2. I'm not bashful -- you judge:
----------------------------------------------------
Poker Chip Forum auction: 560 Vegas World Tournament Hot Stamp chips + paraphernalia
Participants Bloody Marvelous pltrgyst Start date Yesterday at 4:07 PM
Bloody Marvelous Yesterday at 4:07 PM
Hey Pltrgyst,
If you want the set, it's yours.
Could you send me your details and phone number, I can then calculate shipping.
Kind regards,
Eelco
-----
Bloody Marvelous Yesterday at 4:10 PM
I can send the stuff you'd like Bobb to have to France myself if you want. Shipping within the EU will be cheaper than shipping from the US to France.
-----
pltrgyst Yesterday at 4:12 PM
True. I'll have to see what Bobb says he wants.
My address is:
edit
and the phone is edit
Thanks!
-----
Bloody Marvelous Yesterday at 7:09 PM
Hi Larry,
I also got an offer for everything together for the asking price. As I mentioned in my classified post, I prefer to see the set stay together as a whole. Also, Bobb is haggling for a few bucks off, despite my efforts to save him some money in shipping by sending directly to him.
I hope you don't mind, I'm gonna think this over for a bit. I can make 3 people moderately happy with a few chips and photos to add to their existing sets, or make one person really happy with a fantastic combination without any hassles.
-----
pltrgyst Yesterday at 8:13 PM
Eelco,
Well, yeah, I do mind. I said I would take the entire offering, at the asking price, and I was first to respond. I am ready and willing to pay you in full upon receipt of your shipping quote. You are not obligated to do anything else, or to incur any hassles.
What I might have intended to do with them was not restricted in any way by your for sale ad. You were the one who suggested you might help facilitate a secondary sale by shipping to Bobb and/or Coyote, but that is not necessary, if it is an inconvenience for you.
Please just provide me a realistic shipping quote, and I will pay you in full. You ship all to me, and there are no problems. Thank you.
-- Larry
-----
Bloody Marvelous Yesterday at 8:50 PM
Larry,
I'll give you a chance to rephrase that last post.
-- Eelco
-----
pltrgyst Today at 7:36 AM
"Rephrase"? I don't think so. I've said nothing that I wouldn't be willing to post openly on PCF.
You're either a man of your word, or you're not. Simple.
-- Larry
-----
Bloody Marvelous Today at 7:57 AM
That's fair. I probably shouldn't have said "If you want them, they're yours". That's my mistake, and I apologize for that. However, I've tried to be accomodating to you guys, and it feels like that has gone unappreciated at the least.
I just needed a little time to ultimately decide that I should just sell them to you. Had your response been "You can just send everything to me, so you don't have that hassle", that would've sealed the deal.
Ultimately though, they're mine to sell to whomever I want, and right now I'm leaning heavily towards selling them to someone else. For me it makes no difference effort wise, other than that I'll feel better knowing I sent them to someone who'll appreciate them, and with whom I've had a constructive and pleasant conversation. If you feel that I'm not a man of my word if I decide to go that way, I'm sure I'll be able to live with that. No money has changed hands, so I'm under no obligation to send them to anyone yet.
-----
pltrgyst
Today at 2:34 PM
>That's fair. I probably shouldn't have said "If you want them, they're yours". That's my mistake, and I apologize for that. However, I've tried to be accomodating to you guys, and it feels like that has gone unappreciated at the least.
I don't know why you would feel that way. I think your offer to ship some items to Bobb was definitely appreciated by me, and should have been by Bobb. I was kind of appalled to hear that he was negotiating price with you -- that should not have been.... BTW, I'm not making anything off Bobb and Coyote, just trying to help them out.
>I just needed a little time to ultimately decide that I should just sell them to you. Had your response been "You can just send everything to me, so you don't have that hassle", that would've sealed the deal.
That was always the case, and I think I said so very clearly -- twice -- above: "Please just provide me a realistic shipping quote, and I will pay you in full. You ship all to me, and there are no problems." and "I said I would take the entire offering, at the asking price ... I am ready and willing to pay you in full upon receipt of your shipping quote. You are not obligated to do anything else, or to incur any hassles."
>Ultimately though, they're mine to sell to whomever I want, and right now I'm leaning heavily towards selling them to someone else. For me it makes no difference effort wise, other than that I'll feel better knowing I sent them to someone who'll appreciate them, and with whom I've had a constructive and pleasant conversation. If you feel that I'm not a man of my word if I decide to go that way, I'm sure I'll be able to live with that. No money has changed hands, so I'm under no obligation to send them to anyone yet.
They are certainly legally yours to sell to whomever you want, but there are rules and customs within PCF as well. They may not have legally-enforceable consequences, but they do have an effect on your reputation and your future dealings within PCF (not to mention future dealings in general between European and US PCFers). I've wrestled with the same principles when selling, and you can see [*] wrestling with the same problem right now in some of his ads.
It's not Earth-shattering to me. At one point, I owned 3/4 of all the Vegas Worlds, and I sold most of them. I have a nice STT set of 500+ left, and I don't really need any more. I offered to buy yours because I like to see rare larger sets stay together as much as possible, and these were being broken up all over the place. In the seven year history of PCF, there has been no one who has appreciated these chips more than I have. The evidence is there in posts for all to see, and has been quoted by others in selling their Vegas Worlds.
As to your word, you can be your own judge. Your word in PCF was that you would sell the entire lot to the first person who was willing to pay your asking price. Now you're saying that is not the case. It's that simple: You have refused to provide a shipping quote, accept payment, and ship the offered goods, thereby negating our contract. And there it ends.
-- Larry