Going with the example given on time stamps. I believe the auction ended with the $51 bid. @TheB00T, your thoughts? Maybe if one of the mods wants to chime in.....
I won an auction a few weeks ago with essentially the same dilemma. We used the time stamps as the deciding factor in that one as well. I am going to call it a night and check on this in the morning.
I thought it was still going, but it goes to Justin either way. I bailed at $85 despite the confusion so it's just a matter of you two (and mods or whatever) agreeing on the winning bid.