Considering my own criteria, aztar $25 was the best choice, even if it isnt the only aztar of my set.
Reasons :
1- the flashy green is awesome, other green seem just ordinary.
2- I need a red $ value on the down half of the inlay
3- I need a shaped inlay
For reasons 1 & 2,
PCA is out, and i havent found any real other possibility instead of my aztar 25
In your case, we cant answer you while we dont know what are your other choices for the other values.
The real question isnt "which one you prefer", but "which one will match better with the others"... That's much more complicated to answer.
Recently I saw a sale of blue chip quarters, and figure i could add a rack of it and a rack of $1 to make my set mixed for cash and tourney. Those 25c blue chip were amazing, but impossible to find a good $1 which could match with it and the rest of my set.
GL in your quest !