TheYeti
3 of a Kind
we do small games. $20 buy in and 25 and 50 cent blinds
Only 40 big blinds? That's pretty short, isn't it? What's a typical opening raise at your game?
we do small games. $20 buy in and 25 and 50 cent blinds
it is short but that's all the kids wanna play for at one time. opening bud is normally $2. they don't make sense they only play for 20 at a time but will have multiple buy ins lol
.25/.50How .25/.25 blinds?
it is short but that's all the kids wanna play for at one time. opening bud is normally $2. they don't make sense they only play for 20 at a time but will have multiple buy ins lol
Match the stack makes so much sense!We play 25c/25c with a buy in of $50 and then it becomes match the stack.
We do match the big stack at our game as well. Detractors argue however (and rightly so) that it puts stronger players at an advantage vs. weaker players who run up a stack early. i.e. stronger players can just add on and go after the weaker players' stacks.Match the stack makes so much sense!
Ya, I've never liked the idea of match the stack...I often see people justify it by saying "but but but, how can they possibly win their money back if they can't re-buy to match the big stack??"Absolutely match no more than HALF the big stack, or you are allowing players who have the financial capability to use their pocket as a weapon. Let alone with uncapped buy-ins.
If a maniac or quasi-maniac player demands 20BBs in every hand for a flop, sorry the game isn't true to its supposed stakes (blinds).
If a person has chosen to play in that game based on blinds, he may very well NOT have the financial liquidity in the pocket, required to see the maniac to his demise and profit from it.
And don't tell me our player has to tighten-up, because how much can you tighten-up before your big pairs are obvious to everybody?
Agree with this 100%, and makes the game feel more about just the money rather than enjoying playing cardsYa, I've never liked the idea of match the stack...I often see people justify it by saying "but but but, how can they possibly win their money back if they can't re-buy to match the big stack??"
Idk, how about you play better...
I will put a caveat and say it can depend on your group. If you are a tight knit group that isn't taking advantage of your friends and match the stack is used "conservatively", or if you do match half the stack, then I can see the appeal. But past that and when friends of friends or randoms are involved I think it's a bad idea in general.Agree with this 100%, and makes the game feel more about just the money rather than enjoying playing cards
Yup I've mainly seen it happen with the latter scenario - most of my players are long time friends or people I've met at other games in the area. It's really the tone of the game that matters to me the most. Similarly, when everyone has bought in a couple times and the average stack is $100+ it makes sense to allow people to buy in for more, and not feel like they are perpetually short stacked.But past that and when friends of friends or randoms are involved I think it's a bad idea in general.
I don't know why @GoJo_Dingo would want to be able to buy in for so much when he just goes from big stack to felt in 3 hands anyway@goeckerd I’m not ready for this craziness!
So why any complaint then? I'm only helping you guys out...I don't know why @GoJo_Dingo would want to be able to buy in for so much when he just goes from big stack to felt in 3 hands anyway![]()
@GoJo_Dingo @goeckerd I’d like a match-the-stack game every once in a blue moon, but I’d feel bad for any newer guys who aren’t used to playing so deep. Once in a blue moon to get out of the comfort zone sounds good to me, maybe for a more special event, birthday or somethingI don't know why @GoJo_Dingo would want to be able to buy in for so much when he just goes from big stack to felt in 3 hands anyway![]()
@goeckerd I’m not ready for this craziness!
Well, the only way a guy that just got felted can get it back quickly is to match the guy that just won his chips; otherwise the big stack just locks up and no one can put him all in. (now that doesn't sound fair to me)@GoJo_Dingo @goeckerd I’d like a match-the-stack game every once in a blue moon, but I’d feel bad for any newer guys who aren’t used to playing so deep. Once in a blue moon to get out of the comfort zone sounds good to me, maybe for a more special event, birthday or something
I think the guy who won the chip should have an advantage. He earned it. Why should the other guys mistakes allow him to buy that big stack advantage?Well, the only way a guy that just got felted can get it back is to match the guy that just won his chips; otherwise the big stack just locks up and no one can put him all in.
One persons mistake (or rather misfortune) or another persons LUCK on the river? InterestingI think the guy who won the chip should have an advantage. He earned it. Why should the other guys mistakes allow him to buy that big stack advantage?
Well, the only way a guy that just got felted can get it back quickly is to match the guy that just won his chips; otherwise the big stack just locks up and no one can put him all in. (now that doesn't sound fair to me)
Hmmm maybe we should have a new thread with a poll? I’d like to hear what other PCF members think.I think the guy who won the chip should have an advantage. He earned it. Why should the other guys mistakes allow him to buy that big stack advantage?
Not necessarily, the short stack can realize his equity better and more quickly than the deep stacked player. It’s easier to go all in with 20BBs with top pair top kicker, than going all in risking 400BBs with two pair (thinking back to another time @GoJo_Dingo took my 400BB big stack when I went all in and my two pair was counterfeitOne persons mistake (or rather misfortune) or another persons LUCK on the river? Interesting
So if player A goes ALL IN at the turn with the best hand and player B calls and wins by shear luck he should be protected from anyone matching his stack?
For the record, I am ALL IN favor of anyone matching MY big stack at any time during the game (it is truly a disadvantage or foolish to play short-stacked)