Sorry to keep bringing this back up, but I never closed out this thread like I said I would. Some closing thoughts that I hope might help others:
I’m happy with the way the table turned out given the low budget I kept myself on.
I love playing on a round table. I like being able to see everyone and how much easier the dealing is.
I don’t think I will ever do nail heads again. It does dress it up, but it's just not my style. I did it with this table because I was worried about having to stretch the whisper vinyl even further, so it was sort of a necessity.
The 58” size is nice. I would say perfect for 7, might be a little tight for 8, but should be OK. The only game I played on it was with 7. I chose 58” because of 2 factors: 1) was worried about stretching 54” vinyl bigger, 2) Some people said that 60” was a little big to reach pots. Based on my limited time with it so far, I would go with 60” next time, just for the extra room.
DON’T order the cheaper suited speed cloth from
Amazon. It’s just flat out inferior to the good stuff in every way. When it came, I immediately contacted
Amazon and told them it was defective and to ship a replacement. The two main problems with it were 1) it was 8” shorter than the 3 yards it said it was, 2) there were many defects in the weave. It’s hard to explain, but white uncolored lines show in spots. The replacement cloth came and it was even worse! Discoloration in numerous spots. I wound up keeping the first one because I had a game coming up in a few days and I wanted it done. It was under $20. I will probably use it for a while and have to redo it way before any other cloth.
The only other cost cutting measure I would not recommend is the carpet padding. I can’t really put my finger on what exactly about it I don’t like, but I just don’t like it. Could just be the combination of it and the cheap cloth.