Have Chinese cards mold replica sets gone too far? (14 Viewers)

hero_Mcdowells_edit.jpg
 
In general it seems like there isn't as much of a concerted effort to avoid copyright infringements, or anything close to it, as there used to be here.
When PCA's were all the rage, art ownership was so respected here, I felt obligated to contact the acting holder of the PCA copyright to get permission to have a few custom buttons made. Now, there are "replica" sets posted almost daily.

I don't care either way, just pointing out the shift that has occurred in the custom chip hobby.
 
Meddler2 said:
In general it seems like there isn't as much of a concerted effort to avoid copyright infringements, or anything close to it, as there used to be here.
When PCA's were all the rage, art ownership was so respected here, I felt obligated to contact the acting holder of the PCA copyright to get permission to have a few custom buttons made. Now, there are "replica" sets posted almost daily.

I don't care either way, just pointing out the shift that has occurred in the custom chip hobby.
Click to expand...
surprised no one had made PCA cards mold yet given their popularity
 
davislane said:
surprised no one had made PCA cards mold yet given their popularity
Click to expand...
IMO the PCA inlay design is on the blah side. It's better than many but overall lacks imagination and doesn't muster imagination. Don't get me wrong, they are nice chips, but maybe the lackluster design is holding back a full-on cards mold copy...err I mean tribute effort? My opinion may be in the minority but there it is.
 
Meddler2 said:
IMO the PCA inlay design is on the blah side. It's better than many but overall lacks imagination and doesn't muster imagination. Don't get me wrong, they are nice chips, but maybe the lackluster design is holding back a full-on cards mold copy...err I mean tribute effort? My opinion may be in the minority but there it is.
Click to expand...
I think PCA's popularity isn't so much their visual appeal as their feel - they're leaded THCs with shaped textured inlays in near mint condition. That doesn't translate to cards mold.
 
Johnblue said:
Yes, both awesome! Love when people do full art on the ceramics. That’s the only redeeming quality. :)
Click to expand...
Only way to fly in my opinion. Besides feel I think the main reason people don’t like ceramics is they are misused as a product. Why create an inferior version of a clay chip when you can make something completely unique?
 
Mr Tree said:
Only way to fly in my opinion. Besides feel I think the main reason people don’t like ceramics is they are misused as a product. Why create an inferior version of a clay chip when you can make something completely unique?
Click to expand...
Because it's cheap, fast, exactly the spots I want, and I don't have $8 a chip money.
 
Meddler2 said:
Wonder what the Empress Star cards mold tribute sets will look like?
Click to expand...
I commisioned an Aurora Star tribute set (not a direct copy) with permission..... it's a T100-base set with salmon T1000 (instead of blaze orange) and with the original blood red T5 converted to T100k. Hot-stamp font and details are slightly altered from the originals.
 
upNdown said:
I think PCA's popularity isn't so much their visual appeal as their feel - they're leaded THCs with shaped textured inlays in near mint condition. That doesn't translate to cards mold.
Click to expand...
I think the inlay design is simple, classy and descret. It's a much better design than many (maybe even most) other casino inlays. A bright white inlay with no ugly elements ruining the design.
 
Marius L said:
I think the inlay design is simple, classy and descret. It's a much better design than many (maybe even most) other casino inlays. A bright white inlay with no ugly elements ruining the design.
Click to expand...
^^ very true. Most casino inlays are poorly designed; compared to the level of artistry we see on custom sets posted here almost daily. Most of which are absolutely stunning.
 
BlueChipSpecial said:
I have been reading this thread and contemplating the various opinions, viewpoints, and arguments/counter-arguments and have come to the following conclusion:

This thread belongs in the politics section.
Click to expand...
Not even close. The politics forum is for bloodsport (read: forced gemetria therapy, Frogzilla Logic Leaping, and a relentless, unyielding, crushing volume of quasi-topic-related TikTok videos consisting of fat people on their couches bemoaning the government’s granular control over their life.)
 
My main issue with cards molds is that China has absolutely no respect for intellectual property. Just because they don't, doesn't mean we should condone that behaviour by buying direct replicas of chips that we have no rights to. Theft is theft - whether you're stealing a snickers bar from a 7-11 or stealing someone else's design.
 
Darson said:
My main issue with cards molds is that China has absolutely no respect for intellectual property. Just because they don't, doesn't mean we should condone that behaviour by buying direct replicas of chips that we have no rights to. Theft is theft - whether you're stealing a snickers bar from a 7-11 or stealing someone else's design.
Click to expand...
If the corporate overlords at 7-11 didn’t want me to take their Milky Ways, they should have gone to greater length to physically secure them.
 
Darson said:
My main issue with cards molds is that China has absolutely no respect for intellectual property. Just because they don't, doesn't mean we should condone that behaviour by buying direct replicas of chips that we have no rights to. Theft is theft - whether you're stealing a snickers bar from a 7-11 or stealing someone else's design.
Click to expand...
But if I'm stealing windows XP it's fine in 2006.... It's fine. Theoretically I mean
 
I think lack of respect for IP, copyright, and trademark is/was prevalent prior to cards mold chips.

Seems pretty common to see inlay replacements using the actual name and designs of casinos. Ie. People murdering chips and making their own fracs to match a set from a Chip Room sale. A noob could easily be fooled into thinking these were legit chips.
 
TheDuke said:
I think lack of respect for IP, copyright, and trademark is/was prevalent prior to cards mold chips.

Seems pretty common to see inlay replacements using the actual name and designs of casinos. Ie. People murdering chips and making their own fracs to match a set from a Chip Room sale. A noob could easily be fooled into thinking these were legit chips.
Click to expand...
Not from reputable vendors - they would not create a label for a live property. The chips are no longer legit if the property has closed - they're just worthless clay discs.

Even CPC won't use inlays identical to chips no longer in use - the inlays have to be different (either have commemorative or some other change).
 
TheDuke said:
I think lack of respect for IP, copyright, and trademark is/was prevalent prior to cards mold chips.

Seems pretty common to see inlay replacements using the actual name and designs of casinos. Ie. People murdering chips and making their own fracs to match a set from a Chip Room sale. A noob could easily be fooled into thinking these were legit chips.
Click to expand...
If you complain about IP you better not have a Blue lives Matter Skull (Punisher ripoffs) or one of those stickers with the kid that looks like Calvin peeing.
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account and join our community. It's easy!

Register

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Similar threads

Santa123
  • Poll
POLL: Have Chinese cards mold replica sets gone too far?
Replies
12
Views
1K
Santa123
Santa123
B
My thoughts & decision after analyzing 11 popular sample sets
Replies
25
Views
1K
MJM
M
leo822
Advocating For A Better Chip Museum and Explaining Set Collecting to the Chipboard
2 3
Replies
62
Views
5K
DMack
DMack
Taghkanic
The End of Chipping History — ?
2
Replies
46
Views
5K
allforcharity
allforcharity
Irish
Tolkien / LOTR Inspired T-Mold Hot Stamps
2
Replies
37
Views
5K
allforcharity
allforcharity
Back
Top Bottom