As for CPC, I have some Atlantic Club samples and some Key West samples. To be honest, the samples are of pretty bad qualities. The clay material looks dirty and some spot patterns are falling off. They also feel too chalky when you shuffle them. I like the feel of Paulson chips. It's like a right combination of clay and plastic. I know CPC is proud of their craftsmanship but I don't really see that on the samples. They are even more expensive than Paulson. I don't know if custom chips are gonna change my opinion. I've seen some beautiful custom chips on the forum.
Ok I will try to address because I've seen what he's talking about and think I can talk to it.
1. Clay material seems dirty
Two things here. You could be talking about the brass flakes in the weighted colors but I know you aren't. What you are referring to is the cross contamination of other colors and even sometimes minor bits of material into the clay. Yes. It's a very manual process making these chips and each chip / batch of chips can be different. So many different production runs spanning many years and many human hands.
The majority of
CPC chips have no contamination. But I do see something in like 1% of chips. (Photos can be provided upon request) but I also have some Paulsons that have contamination too. It happens sometimes.
2. Edge spots falling off.
I know it seems crazy but if he's referring to the $25 Key West chip, I have an example of this in my own collection where the 312 spot seems to not have adhered correctly to the main chip. I have a tiny set of examples where the clay material actually seems "cracked" along the spot edge which I could easily see someone as saying it's "falling off". It's not really falling off.... it's just not a perfect adherence.
Again, photos upon request. I have this downstairs but I'm lazy at 5am.
3. Too chalky when shuffling.
CPC formula to me seems a bit on the harder side but I can attest that after the chips are broken into, they become soft and rounded and slide together like cold butter (unlike warm buttery goodness of Paulson).
Have to break em in. Take a little while. They only get better with age.
LASTLY...
When
CPC chips are brand new, there is some chip dust in the mold. Wash it with warm water... hell even squirt a drop or two of mineral or baby oil in there while you're at it and that shit clears up real fast.
Just want to make sure that "dirty" isn't misinterpreted as just "dusty".