Using a similar color for the edge spots (1 Viewer)

[Hokuto789]

Hello.
I'm planning to make a custom poker chip with CPC.

I have a consultation.
How about using a similar color for the edge spots on the chip?
I plan to use white, black, pink, and yellow for the edge spots of each chip (see image).
The base color is based on the Paulson chip.

The reason for unifying this color is based on the theme color of a certain game character.
I feel that if the color of the edge spots is the same, the visibility will deteriorate. What about?
Please let the opinion of everyone.

Note
This sentence was created by Google Translate.
If there is a strange expression, please forgive me.

 

[allforcharity]

This may be very difficult to do well. If you are going to try to use only black, pink, and yellow for the edge spots, then I would use base chip colours that are NOT black, pink, or yellow.

 

[Quicksilver-75]

I think you *could* get it to work if you used chip colors that offered a higher contrast. Ie: Rather than yellow for a base, try DG yellow. If you use various shades you could have the same effect and still use a small gamut.
Blurple with black is risky as well. Blurple is a VERY saturated color and without spots that will make it easily identifiable from the surface and sides, will almost certainly lead to dirty stack issues with your black chips.

 

[BGinGA]

Don't do it. It sounds reasonable in theory, but it rarely turns out well -- and often produces multiple dirty stack opportunities.

 

[RainmanTrail]

ようこそ! I think you would make a better looking set if you used more colors. When you repeat colors, some chips can look too similar in stacks (this is what we call "dirty stacks"). Perhaps a better idea is to create a more balanced looking set with the chips and edge spot colors, but then you can use your game characters on the inlay artwork instead. You could use a different game character for each chip.

 

[Thomacetti]

hard no...

Using different tints next to base color....sometimes FANTASTIC sometimes meh
Look at HoF sets for inspiration and don't hold back asking for feedback.

 

[Hokuto789]

Thank you for replying!

Look at HoF sets for inspiration and don't hold back asking for feedback.

What the HoF Sets?

 

[Thomacetti]

HoF = Hall of Fame

 

[RainmanTrail]

Thank you for replying!

What the HoF Sets?

https://www.pokerchipforum.com/resources/categories/hall-of-fame.6/

 

[surfik]

Fix the pink one, rest is good

 

[detroitdad]

Don't do it. It sounds reasonable in theory, but it rarely turns out well -- and often produces multiple dirty stack opportunities.

this..........plus the black chip will look like an expensive dice chip