Is this the Protege button that both of you guys may have? This is the one Sidepot Poker used to sell. Who knows if they even are in business even any longer, but their site is up. They haven't had it in stock for years. I'd be backup for a spare of this button one of you guys may have after @jja412 gets his button.
I have two like that, but one is damaged. I also have a third that is noticeably different. It has more of a matte finish and slightly different print colors - from memory, it's a little bluer and not as dark. I have no idea if that one was also sold by Sidepot or if it was a 3rd party production.