PCF's Favorite Chips...what's next (1 Viewer)

[FDLmold]

Thinking about doing some more pron threads and polls. Clearly Paulson THC casino chips made between 1975 and 1995 are the best chips ever, since they won all 11 favorite casino chip polls. Maybe 10 of 11, not sure when the Flamingo $1 was made.

Other molds and manufacturers need some time in the spotlight too! I was thinking of going through all 11 colors again, no Paulsons allowed, but casino AND custom AND fantasy chips would be allowed. It would essentially be "PCF's favorite *color* non-Paulson chip". I think that might be fun. Any thoughts?

 

[Rbonus012]

Send it!

 

[davislane]

definitely. let's head towards a champions of champions poll eventually

 

[Mac128k]

I think a fantasy only bracket would be fun.

 

[sadwallet]

Would really enjoy this

 

[upNdown]

Meh. Customs voting leans toward popularity contests; I’d leave them out.

 

[Rieguy]

Thinking about doing some more pron threads and polls. Clearly Paulson THC casino chips made between 1975 and 1995 are the best chips ever, since they won all 11 favorite casino chip polls. Maybe 10 of 11, not sure when the Flamingo $1 was made.

Other molds and manufacturers need some time in the spotlight too! I was thinking of going through all 11 colors again, no Paulsons allowed, but casino AND custom AND fantasy chips would be allowed. It would essentially be "PCF's favorite *color* non-Paulson chip". I think that might be fun. Any thoughts?

My only suggestion would be that instead of the prior format, we do something more like a March Madness bracket once all of the nominations are in. I feel like that way people will not have to split votes between certain chips in certain heats. This would probably be more work for you, but I do think we could wind up with more participation and more representative results.

Either way, I appreciate you doing these; it has been fun and I have learned about some incredible chips I never knew existed.

 

[Eloe2000]

We did the favorite colors, but what about non base color chips like quarter pies and dovetails that weren’t considered because they had no base color?

 

[Eloe2000]

Also, “favorite complete set” as in the cohesive full denom set design.

 

[upNdown]

I think ya done good.
We can have a best ceramic contest if you really need something to do, but I think your work here is done.

 

[RichMahogany]

Most hated chips

 

[Thomacetti]

I would LOVE to see a combo/set contest with a fixed budget....could help to show what is available for what price.
It's always great to look at awsome pr0n...but most of those sets are only for the happy few.

Would be great to see so many creative minds find an optimal way to get a great set 'on the cheap'

I would create 3 brackets for cash & 3 for tourney

Cash (max $500 & max 1000$)
1 table set with dimes breakdown
1 table set with quarters breakdown
1 table with 1/2 breakdown

Tourney (max $500 & max 1000$)
1 table set with 5/25/100/500/1000 breakdown
1 table set with 25/100/500/1000/5000 breakdown
2 table set

 

[BGinGA]

Most hated chips

This has real potential. A complete set of the worst chips ever, determined by voter polling.

 

[Sprouty]

Worst chips by color?

Red, what's that Aztar fiver that ruined the lineup?

 

[FDLmold]

Most hated chips

I love this. Have to keep customs out of it, but fantasy, casino, and casinos that never existed would all be eligible.

 

[FDLmold]

Worst chips by color?

Red, what's that Aztar fiver that ruined the lineup?

Red Aztar Caruthersville $5. In that lineup, it was a 100% POFS.

 

[Perthmike]

I love this. Have to keep customs out of it, but fantasy, casino, and casinos that never existed would all be eligible.

Please do it. But yeah maybe no customs or maybe haha, that would be impolite

 

[FDLmold]

A person, could, however, nominate their *own* custom chip. Sort of like a "roast me". That could fly. But no nominating somebody else's. That's rude.

 

[ovo]

Best CiC chips

 

[FDLmold]

Best CiC chips

That seems boring. Aren't they all from Puerto Rico and Aruba?

 

[davislane]

I love this. Have to keep customs out of it, but fantasy, casino, and casinos that never existed would all be eligible.

what category do NAGBs fall under?

 

[BGinGA]

what category do NAGBs fall under?

Not eligible imo. Any chip designed/ordered shouldn't be included.