PB&...? What’s your favorite peanut butter sandwich? (1 Viewer)

[Beakertwang]

If you’re like me, peanut butter sandwiches were a staple of your childhood diet. I still enjoy them from time to time.

What’s your favorite combo? Jif or Skippy? Creamy or chunky? Any weird or interesting combinations?

I’m mostly a Creamy Jif guy. My favorite is PB and sliced banana. I also like PB and honey.

Tonight, it’s grilled PB on wheat with blackberry preserves.

 

[BGinGA]

Creamy Jif with grape jelly, blackberry jam, or sliced bananas. Also good with Nutella.

 

[Saoliver]

I liked chunky as a kid, with dill pickles. I’ve now got my son loving them.

Now it’s creamy Jif or Skippy, with raspberry or blackberry jam. Honey is good too.

 

[Thisfiendis138]

If you’re like me, peanut butter sandwiches were a staple of your childhood diet. I still enjoy them from time to time.

What’s your favorite combo? Jif or Skippy? Creamy or chunky? Any weird or interesting combinations?

I’m mostly a Creamy Jif guy. My favorite is PB and sliced banana. I also like PB and honey.

Tonight, it’s grilled PB on wheat with blackberry preserves.
View attachment 468862

That melty PB

 

[Thisfiendis138]

Peanut Butter & Company has some good stuff.

My favorite

 

[FordPickup92]

Jif all the way, 100%
I prefer creamy but I love chunky from time to time. Chunky, Peter pan only

Also. I love honey wheat or oat bread, with BlackBerry preserves or raspberry preserves. But my ultimate fav is just PB with PB on one slice of bread folded in half. I also love melted PB on my ice cream, ALWAYS.

Btw, grilled PB dipped in jam/preserves is such an amazeballs idea. I used to eat English muffins and bagels toasted with PB for breakfast. My diet doesn't allow PB more than once a week now (usually a Saturday or Sunday treat)

 

[Ellasdaddy]

Dense bread, like Dave's Killer Bread, Jif creamy, grape jelly, sliced banana, breakfast cereal... my current kick is raisin bran. Checks the heart-healthy box. Sometimes honey nut cheerios hit the spot.

 

[IaHawk]

Strawberry Jelly/Jam.

 

[Thisfiendis138]

I prefer creamy but I love chunky from time to time. Chunky, Peter pan only

This!
But the Honey Roasted Crunchy

 

[FordPickup92]

This!
But the Honey Roasted Crunchy
View attachment 468880

Honey roasted or super chunk

 

[MegaTon44]

Peanut butter and jelly hot dog sandwich

 

[12thMan]

Peanut butter as smooth as you can make it and orange juice as pulpy as it can be. If I could drink my peanut butter through a straw and eat my orange juice with a fork I’d be in heaven.

regular jelly or bananas as far as what to put on it. A slight nod to jelly forbeing a classic but banana is actually better.

 

[12thMan]

Hot dog buns are actually one of the best breads to have pb&j on. For some reason it just works perfectly. Nice one @MegaTon44

 

[FordPickup92]

Hot dog buns are actually one of the best breads to have pb&j on. For some reason it just works perfectly. Nice one @MegaTon44

Potato bread 100%

 

[Thisfiendis138]

Honey roasted or super chunk

 

[Thisfiendis138]

Potato bread 100%

Martin’s

 

[Josh Kifer]

WHEN I THROW IT IN THE TRASH.

 

[FordPickup92]

Martin’s

Yes

WHEN I THROW IT IN THE TRASH.

YOU THROW PB IN THE TRASH AND I WILL BURN YOU AND TAKE YOUR DOG

 

[Josh Kifer]

Yes

YOU THROW PB IN THE TRASH AND I WILL BURN YOU AND TAKE YOUR DOG

PB IS DOG FOOD HERE BECAUSE PB IS GROSS AND NOT FOR HUMANS.

 

[pltrgyst]

I can't stand peanut flavor in any form. My wife knows that sticking a knife first in peanut butter and then in the raspberry jam is grounds for immediate divorce.

But growing up, the kids of the Georgia family living next door used to thrive on peanut butter and sugar sandwiches.

 

[FordPickup92]

PB IS DOG FOOD HERE BECAUSE PB IS GROSS AND NOT FOR HUMANS.

I retract my tacos from you. This is not acceptable

 

[Saoliver]

PB IS DOG FOOD HERE BECAUSE PB IS GROSS AND NOT FOR HUMANS.

PB is an American staple. Let me guess: you don’t like Spam either?

 

[Josh Kifer]

PB is an American staple. Let me guess: you don’t like Spam either?

I love Spam actually. Hahaha

PB is fine, I'm just not a huge fan. About once a year I'll have a PB&J... Then, I'm good for a year.

 

[FordPickup92]

I love Spam actually. Hahaha

PB is fine, I'm just not a huge fan. About once a year I'll have a PB&J... Then, I'm good for a year.

To be fair I ate spam as a kid, and now I hate it

 

[Perthmike]

The only correct answer is dark roast peanut butter with no sugar and other crap added in. It tastes amazing.

Oh and I'm in the "it needs butter" camp. Tastes so much better with butter

I grew up eating skippys actually that I used to buy in bulk from Costco lol but I've seen the light now.

 

[RichMahogany]

All natural smooth peanut butter and honey

 

[FordPickup92]

The only correct answer is dark roast peanut butter with no sugar and other crap added in. It tastes amazing.

Oh and I'm in the "it needs butter" camp. Tastes so much better with butter

I grew up eating skippys actually that I used to buy in bulk from Costco lol but I've seen the light now.
View attachment 468885
View attachment 468887

For the record, I liked this post because I agree with the PB aspect here, but I dont know that I can even fathom butter on a PB sammy

 

[legend672]

You mooks never had a fluffanutter ? marshmallow fluff and peanut butter on white .Made locally on Lynn, Mass.
Lynn Lynn city of sin you never come out the way you went in

 

[gopherblue]

All natural PB. With lingonberry preserves.

The guy who came up with the grilled PB, banana and bacon sandwich was definitely on to something.

 

[FiveThous]

Jif creamy peanut butter on wheat bread. That's it, that's the sandwich.