My opinion is I would definitely go
CSQ over elephant head, personally. More importantly, I have to be honest and say that I prefer your first
CSQ mockup the most by far. The reason being is that both the inlay itself, “Le Gold” and being black and gold, and the classy theme it implies goes much better with the colors and edge spots of that first mockup. The later mockup colors and edge spots seem a little more reminiscent of the Outlaw ABS plastic poker chips:
I don’t think the colors of the newer mockups work well with that inlay. The colors from the first mockup are much more cohesive to the inlay. Only some minor tweaks here or there would warrant looking into.
So going off the first
CSQ mockups and edge spots, maybe I’d make these tweaks?:
$1 chip - lighten the dark blue base color to imperial blue
$100 chip - lighten the orange edge spot to dayglo peach
$5,000 chip - change the black edge spot to dayglo green or green
$25,000 chip - brighten the pink base color to dayglo pink, and then lighten the blue edge spot to imperial blue
Ultimately always take any suggestions here with a grain of salt, maybe some will help and some won’t, some will be based on those who only prefer chips 1 certain way at all times, and some could be just completely wild and off the wall. At the end of the day, you should go with what makes you truly proud and that you’ll know you can enjoy for a lifetime.