It is recommended to use PayPal Goods and Services when paying for an item. There are no buyer protections when sending PayPal Friends and Family, Zelle, Google Pay, Venmo, CashApp, Crypto, among others.
This is a picture of Cleveland. I don't think many/any Cincy ones were made?
Cleveland has a "gold" horseshoe and Cincy has a "silver/grey" (horseshoe based on the chips).
Doesn't make a difference to me either way!