Jeff, those latest submissions seem pretty busy to me, too. Looking at your (wonderful) set, most of the color combos are elegant and somewhat subdued. Something really flashy doesn't fit well in the top spot, imo. That said, I like these previous submissions as fitting in better with your existing chips:
CHIP ON LEFT:
CHIP ON RIGHT:
CHIP ON RIGHT (NEEDS BLACK INLAY):
Would be a lot better if the chips were The C Club instead of E....
I'd go with the white 1/4 pie chip as well.