Help! Asking for feedback on color and spot choices for a new cash and tournament set (1 Viewer)

JMC9389

Royal Flush
Supporter
Joined
Jul 27, 2019
Messages
12,275
Reaction score
27,634
Location
NJ
Damn this hobby.

Inspiration struck like a lightning bolt earlier this week for a new set inspired by a favorite vacation spot. After seeing the awesome aquatic/beach motif inspired sets from @Eloe2000 , @Rbonus012 , and Fink with his P+P set, I figured I'd try my hand at my own. I'm going to keep the specifics on the down low, but I'm shooting for a Caribbean/beach theme with these chips. I want the colors and edge spots to go along that theme as closely as possible.

It'll be on HHR mold if I ever get these made (the reason will make sense when I explain the back story), and that part is not negotiable for change.

As I won't have any set with shaped inlays, I'll try my hand at it with the cash set with this theme. This is what I have so far, but open to feedback on color, edge spot progression, and inlay shape choices. I'm going to give my thoughts on each chip so far as well below.

Caribbean Cash Set Initial Mock Up.png


Frac: I could go either way here between a red or a green frac. If I go with a green frac though, I'd change the spots on the $1 to red or pink instead of green as is. Maybe go maroon here instead of red? I got my color sample out and I'm just not sure if red provides enough of contrast against the retro red base.

$1: I forgot to change the edge spot pattern on this one before hitting save. I'm likely going to make this 4D14 instead of 4DS18 as I plan on using the latter spot pattern. On my color sample DG Green could work really nicely here, and I don't want to outright copy @Eloe2000 's Casa Mango $1 here, though I won't lie and say that chip is a huge inspiration in thinking this one up. I have a DG Peacock $1 already pending that'll be 3D14, I'm trying to do something different here. I'm flexible with the edge spot pattern here, but as long as it makes sense in the context of the entire set, but am more or less settled on the DG Peacock base and bright white and DG Green or light green spots. Do I rotate the spots 45 degrees to better fit the inlay shape, or is it ok as is?

$5: The first chip I thought of when mocking this set up. This one screams Caribbean and "the beach" to me. I'm really happy with the colors and edge spots as is, but try to change my mind! This shaped inlay works perfectly with the 414418 spot as well!

$20: This was one of the more challenging chips. I already covered so much of the CPC palette in the first three chips and it was hard to think up something that wouldn't cause dirty stack or pot issues. I really want the 3TA316 spot to work here if I can as I don't have a set as of yet with this edge spot in it, and I think the $20 here, especially after a $5 that pops the way it does, is a good place to do it. I'm definitely flexible with the edge spot colors here, I struggled lots in thinking this one up. There may be a good start with the gray and light blue spots on the outside, but I'm trying to find the right color for the third spot in the middle that would provide contrast.

$100: Definitely going white for the base here, but I'm flexible on the spot pattern and edge spot colors. I already know this set will be heavy on the blues, yellows, oranges, and reds, but do I continue with that or do I do something different here? Would love to see some different ideas for this chip and the $20, while the $5, frac, and $1 I'm pretty much set on the colors, at least.

As for the tournament set, I want to do a set with the same edge spot pattern as the others I've made will have different edge spots. Again, going with the Caribbean/beach theme here.

Caribbean Tournament Set Initial Mock Up.png


So I'm pretty happy with the cohesiveness and color scheme of each chip individually in this lineup. I opted for the 4DS18 spot because I don't have many chips that have this spot pattern, and would look good in stacks on the table. It also allows for more of the base chip color to shine through as opposed to the 4DS16 pattern that covers the edge of the chip almost all the way to the inlay. I made the set in a way that is very formulaic; one faded color relative to the chip base and a contrasting color (ex. green spot on a light green base, light blue on an imperial blue base, you get the idea).

Some thoughts:

On the T25, do I make it contrast more and go with dark green or retro green instead of regular green?

T100 I'm very happy with. Maybe arc yellow instead of peach?

T500 looks good too, but maybe DG pink instead of regular pink? I think regular pink is just right to provide contrast but not so much that it's screaming and clashing with the DG Tiger base in the T1000.

T1000 is a banger. I'm happy with that completely. Ditto the T5000.

For the white T25,000, I tried to pick two colors that weren't used yet. DG pink fit the bill as it wasn't used on the T500, and the T500 will be off the table by the time T25,000's would ever make an appearance. Any other ideas for a bright white base chip here? I'm open to different color suggestions here.

Alright, go ahead and roast me!
 
I'm going to keep the specifics on the down low, but I'm shooting for a Caribbean/beach theme with these chips. I want the colors and edge spots to go along that theme as closely as possible. It'll be on HHR mold if I ever get these made (the reason will make sense when I explain the back story), and that part is not negotiable for change.

I feel like I know where you are going with this and I dig it. Reminds me of times in costa rica at a point when I used to go every year.

As I won't have any set with shaped inlays, I'll try my hand at it with the cash set with this theme. This is what I have so far, but open to feedback on color, edge spot progression, and inlay shape choices. I'm going to give my thoughts on each chip so far as well below.

I originally had sort of a random progression but worked myself into a more traditional one. Everyone talked me into go with the HUB $5 but damn is that a pricey choice. I kind of wish I went with TRI on my $1s which would have carried over from my WTHC set and then went Scallop $20/25 and COG $100 to be almost totally traditional. But SCA is pretty much my favorite shape and the $1s are our workhorse. I would shoot to put your favorite shapes on the $1 and $5 workhorse chips are just go straight traditional spot progression.

View attachment 892623

Frac: I could go either way here between a red or a green frac. If I go with a green frac though, I'd change the spots on the $1 to red or pink instead of green as is. Maybe go maroon here instead of red? I got my color sample out and I'm just not sure if red provides enough of contrast against the retro red base.

I am really digging Red and Pink combos and kind of wish I was able to make that work. I love @JeepologyOffroad 's frac. It is my fav. If I do another tournament set I am going to work the red/dg pink combo on a chip.

$1: I forgot to change the edge spot pattern on this one before hitting save. I'm likely going to make this 4D14 instead of 4DS18 as I plan on using the latter spot pattern. On my color sample DG Green could work really nicely here, and I don't want to outright copy @Eloe2000 's Casa Mango $1 here, though I won't lie and say that chip is a huge inspiration in thinking this one up. I have a DG Peacock $1 already pending that'll be 3D14, I'm trying to do something different here. I'm flexible with the edge spot pattern here, but as long as it makes sense in the context of the entire set, but am more or less settled on the DG Peacock base and bright white and DG Green or light green spots. Do I rotate the spots 45 degrees to better fit the inlay shape, or is it ok as is?

Go ahead and copy it if you wanted. But my green is Light Green on the $1 since I was using DG Green as a base on my $20. Also it looks kind of like a seafoam green which was more of what I was specifically going for. If that is what you want go for that. As a pure color combo DG Peacock and DG Green work better IMO.

$5: The first chip I thought of when mocking this set up. This one screams Caribbean and "the beach" to me. I'm really happy with the colors and edge spots as is, but try to change my mind! This shaped inlay works perfectly with the 414418 spot as well!

Amazing. My fav spot pattern.

$20: This was one of the more challenging chips. I already covered so much of the CPC palette in the first three chips and it was hard to think up something that wouldn't cause dirty stack or pot issues. I really want the 3TA316 spot to work here if I can as I don't have a set as of yet with this edge spot in it, and I think the $20 here, especially after a $5 that pops the way it does, is a good place to do it. I'm definitely flexible with the edge spot colors here, I struggled lots in thinking this one up. There may be a good start with the gray and light blue spots on the outside, but I'm trying to find the right color for the third spot in the middle that would provide contrast.

I noticed you don't have any purple/retro lavender/lavender etc in the set. Perhaps an opportunity here if you are not happy with the spot colors?

$100: Definitely going white for the base here, but I'm flexible on the spot pattern and edge spot colors. I already know this set will be heavy on the blues, yellows, oranges, and reds, but do I continue with that or do I do something different here? Would love to see some different ideas for this chip and the $20, while the $5, frac, and $1 I'm pretty much set on the colors, at least.

Ship it.

As for the tournament set, I want to do a set with the same edge spot pattern as the others I've made will have different edge spots. Again, going with the Caribbean/beach theme here.

View attachment 892624

So I'm pretty happy with the cohesiveness and color scheme of each chip individually in this lineup. I opted for the 4DS18 spot because I don't have many chips that have this spot pattern, and would look good in stacks on the table. It also allows for more of the base chip color to shine through as opposed to the 4DS16 pattern that covers the edge of the chip almost all the way to the inlay. I made the set in a way that is very formulaic; one faded color relative to the chip base and a contrasting color (ex. green spot on a light green base, light blue on an imperial blue base, you get the idea).

Some thoughts:

On the T25, do I make it contrast more and go with dark green or retro green instead of regular green?

I like it as is with Green

T100 I'm very happy with. Maybe arc yellow instead of peach?

Nope. Ship it.

T500 looks good too, but maybe DG pink instead of regular pink? I think regular pink is just right to provide contrast but not so much that it's screaming and clashing with the DG Tiger base in the T1000.

Fair point. I would say leave it as-is. If you changed to DG Pink here then I would say you also change the $25 to DG Yellow so that you have DG pop on spots on each of the base chips. But otherwise leave it.
 
Last edited:
The only one I'm not feeling is the purple chip in the tournament set. I guess I feel like the theme is lighter/brighter/happier colors that make you think of being away on a tropical vacation.

So the purple being so dark kinda clashes with that for me. Maybe go with a lighter base color, or maybe switch to a pink base? Although that could cause issues seeing them in stacks or piles when mixed with the orange ones.
 
Thanks guys, I look some feedback and came up with this:

Tournament Set:

Caribbean Tournament Mock Up 2.png


I decided to go with a little more contrast on the T25 with a retro green spot instead of green. I subconsciously must love the light green/green/canary combo as they're my exact colors for my Canoe Club T25 :LOL: :laugh:

I took Anthony's advice and made a more "tropical" looking T500. I really like retro lavender here, but thoughts as to whether this would cause dirty pot/stack issues with DG Tiger T1000's? It doesn't look like it at first glance but not sure if there have been any real life examples yet.

Also still appreciate any suggestions for spot colors on the white base T25,000 chip. I'm not totally sold on that combo yet...

I made two more cash set mockups too with a new $20 and two different versions of the one. I also changed the red spot to maroon to provide a bit more contrast

Better or more messy?

Caribbean Cash Set 2.png


Or do I just go with what I had originally planned for but with a new $20?

Caribbean Cash Set 3.png


I can't make a 3TA316 chip that I like. I like the spot/color combo of the new $20. Thoughts?
 
Thanks guys, I look some feedback and came up with this:

Tournament Set:

View attachment 892918

I decided to go with a little more contrast on the T25 with a retro green spot instead of green. I subconsciously must love the light green/green/canary combo as they're my exact colors for my Canoe Club T25 :LOL: :laugh:

I took Anthony's advice and made a more "tropical" looking T500. I really like retro lavender here, but thoughts as to whether this would cause dirty pot/stack issues with DG Tiger T1000's? It doesn't look like it at first glance but not sure if there have been any real life examples yet.

Also still appreciate any suggestions for spot colors on the white base T25,000 chip. I'm not totally sold on that combo yet...

I made two more cash set mockups too with a new $20 and two different versions of the one. I also changed the red spot to maroon to provide a bit more contrast

Better or more messy?

View attachment 892921

Or do I just go with what I had originally planned for but with a new $20?

View attachment 892922

I can't make a 3TA316 chip that I like. I like the spot/color combo of the new $20. Thoughts?
The new $20 are better with the edge spot as the edge progression is nicer

The fracs and $20 may have some dirty stack issue for red-colour blindness, maybe a brighter colour for frac will be better ? Just my 2 cents

I like the tourney set line-out, not really much I will like to change to that lineout
 
An initial thought I had looking back again after a few minutes is that both the frac and 50 cent chip have two edge spots that drastically clash against the body of the chip, with the maroon spot on the red chip and the dark green spot on the 50 cent chip. Even though the colors are drastically different, it makes the two chips look kind of similar, if that makes sense.

The solution is to soften up the look of one of the chips. I'm leaning towards softening up the green chip, but which spot do I use instead of dark green here?
 
Normally I don’t weigh in on an advice thread but first pics have real potential. Here is what I tell anyone in your shoes.

Base colors first, then Get the inlays done. That is the first step even if you just tinker around with whatever computer skills you have. Once you have the card room, title, font, images, denom style, everything. then start fine tuning until you think the spots are close. Get it all in your head and clearly describe what you want to achieve. That is how every project I’ve done with Johnny has transpired. An artist with his abilities will get you there. He was just mentioning this to me in a message yesterday Since we are tinkering again.

That said, going back to the first pic, all base colors look good. There is a lot of color there. Maybe consider something besides black for the 20/25. You could use Blurple there and maybe you like it better? I like the 5 and hundo but they are too similar. Keep the 5 and change the spots on the hundo

Looking forward to this one.
 
Apologies up front for being new here. Everywhere I looked I saw yellow as the 1k and orange for the 5k for tournament sets. But now I'm starting to see a few of them being swapped. Is there a reason a few tournament sets I'm seeing have them swapped more recently? I know that yellow/orange and orange/gray are standard, but if orange/yellow is also an option, that sounds like the Wild West :D

Also, love these colors and edge spots, but don't know enough about progression to give advice on it =)
 
Apologies up front for being new here. Everywhere I looked I saw yellow as the 1k and orange for the 5k for tournament sets. But now I'm starting to see a few of them being swapped. Is there a reason a few tournament sets I'm seeing have them swapped more recently? I know that yellow/orange and orange/gray are standard, but if orange/yellow is also an option, that sounds like the Wild West :D

Also, love these colors and edge spots, but don't know enough about progression to give advice on it =)
No need for apologies! The beauty of customs is that you can go your own way and do something outside of what's conventional. For my first foray into creating an inlaid custom tournament set, I made a couple of chips in the lineup with base colors that are totally different from what would be considered the "standard" T25 green, T100 blank, T500 purple, T1000 yellow, T5000 orange, etc. But I'm so glad I did because I'm really happy with the final product!


 
Normally I don’t weigh in on an advice thread but first pics have real potential. Here is what I tell anyone in your shoes.

Base colors first, then Get the inlays done. That is the first step even if you just tinker around with whatever computer skills you have. Once you have the card room, title, font, images, denom style, everything. then start fine tuning until you think the spots are close. Get it all in your head and clearly describe what you want to achieve. That is how every project I’ve done with Johnny has transpired. An artist with his abilities will get you there. He was just mentioning this to me in a message yesterday Since we are tinkering again.

That said, going back to the first pic, all base colors look good. There is a lot of color there. Maybe consider something besides black for the 20/25. You could use Blurple there and maybe you like it better? I like the 5 and hundo but they are too similar. Keep the 5 and change the spots on the hundo

Looking forward to this one.
It's funny because I was just thinking the other day about seeing how a purple $20 or $25 would look in this set. I do like the idea of it better, but finding a color combination that works with the rest of the set is going to be what proves the most challenging. Purple certainly does fit the bill better for a tropical or beach themed set, but the other thing I'm also trying to steer clear of is repeating chip base colors between the tournament and cash sets. I think light green for the 50 cent chip in the cash set and the T25 in the tournament set may be the only exception to this, but I haven't decided if DG green will work as a T25 base in the tournament set quite yet.

I'm thinking of going with regular white for either the $100 cash chip or T25,000 tournament chip, but I'm not sure which yet. Leaning towards the latter, but there's plenty to decide.

In general, in my creative process, how you outlined it generally is how it has gone. I mocked up a "good idea" of what I'm going for in terms of chips in other sets I've designed, but once I had inlay artwork that I was happy with, on the Canoe Clubs above especially, I made significant changes on a couple of chips in the set.

I agree with you on the $100. I love it as a standalone chip, but it's too similar in color scheme to the workhorse and the chip I built this set around. Though I abhor DG Saturn in general, I think it may actually work on my latest mock up. I call the new $100 the "Pina Colada" chip.

Caribbean Cash Set 5.png

I don't love retro lavender as an edgespot color here, not sure I'm sold on the gray 1/4 inch spots either. I would like to go with something neutral here, but as is, it clashes too much with the $1, I think.
 
What’s your tournament set denoms going to be? Maybe I missed that but IMO only 4 chips are needed for tournaments.

Or maybe I should post this in the controversial opinion thread ha
T25, T100, T500, T1000, T5000, T25000, and a bounty that I've yet to make.
 
Another idea that struck like a bolt of lightning. In going with a beach/Caribbean theme, each chip can represent a different mixed drink.

NCV red frac: Strawberry Daiquiri
Green 50 cent: Margarita
Blue $1: Blue Lagoon
DG Peach $5: Tequila Sunrise
Purple $20: I'll work on this one. I found something called a Caribbean storm that has cantaloupe and strawberries in it with a purple rum base. Maybe that?
White $100: Pina Colada

The idea is really cool in theory, but my first thought is man, that's a lot of orange and yellow. I still don't love using DG Saturn on the hundo, but it's the best match of what I picture a pina colada to look like when I think of one.
Caribbean Cash Set 7.png
 
I think I like DG green as a T25 base relative to a Imperial blue T100. Works for me as I plan to use a light green half dollar for the cash set.

20220423_194228.jpg
20220423_194234.jpg


DG green on top versus light green on bottom
 
What are the spot colors on the 5000? Lovely chip.
You'll have to ask @PlaidDragon to be sure, but my best guess? Imperial blue base with yellow, chocolate, light chocolate, orange, and DG Peach? The spot at 8 o clock is what I'm not sure of.

And yes, great idea on using brown as a spot on the Pina colada chip! I'm going to mock it up and see how it looks.
 
I prefer light green.
As a base color, I absolutely do as well. I have to get my color sample out again, but on seeing the light green and Imperial blue chips next to each other last night, the two colors next to each other look a little flat if that makes sense. DG green and Imperial blue have much better contrast between each other.
 
I think I like DG green as a T25 base relative to a Imperial blue T100.

Yep. Light green has more of a minty tone to it, I like the DG green here as well for a tropical theme.

If you make it over for cards next weekend, you can compare some barrels, my T25s and T5ks are DG green and imperial blue. Spot colors are actually fairly similar too, now that I'm looking at it.
 
I don't think you'll need a T25K if you start with a base of T25 unless you're running at least 5 tables.

Of course, if you want to change things up and occasionally run T500 base then go for it.
 
I don't think you'll need a T25K if you start with a base of T25 unless you're running at least 5 tables.

Of course, if you want to change things up and occasionally run T500 base then go for it.
I won't for T10,000 starting stacks, yes, but I also like to run T100,000 deepstack games once a year. T100 base with 15/5/11/7/2 starting stacks from T100 upwards. 25K's are needed for this type of game, plus I really liked how T40,000 starting stacks with a T100 base played when I played in a game a couple of months ago.

Anyway, I made a couple of changes to a couple of the tournament chips. Changed the T25 from light green to DG green, and changed the spots from green to retro green and canary to DG yellow.

Changed the T5K from DG yellow to canary base and made the T25K white instead of bright white and made the spots gray and blue instead of pink and retro blue.

Caribbean Tournament Mock Up 3.png

Is the T25K too drab looking now? I do like the new spot color combo...
 
Yep. Light green has more of a minty tone to it, I like the DG green here as well for a tropical theme.

If you make it over for cards next weekend, you can compare some barrels, my T25s and T5ks are DG green and imperial blue. Spot colors are actually fairly similar too, now that I'm looking at it.
Thanks bud, I'm going to try hard, but it's leaning towards not being able to make it. We're having a birthday party for the little guy the next day and may be tied up most of Saturday to set up.
 
You'll have about a 0.5g difference between the weighted and non-weighted base colour chips.

For my own set, I used all weighted colours, and one non-weighted colour out of the two for edge spots, in order to keep total chip weight more consistent.
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account and join our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Back
Top Bottom